10-4. From: Clay Barnett [mailto:cbarnett@addisontx.gov] Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 8:11 AM To: Eric T. Little Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Eric, I have requested resumes from Mr. Farrow. Additionally, I am going to call some suppliers and find out if CPS Civil has been paying their bills. I believe I can gather more information, but I may need additional time and it may not change the outcome. Just some food for thought. Thanks, Clay Barnett, P.E. Town Engineer Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, TX 75001-2818 Office: (972) 450-2857 From: Eric T. Little [mailto:ELittle@udr.com] Sent: Monday, February 28, 2011 8:03 AM To: Clay Barnett Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Clay, Nick’s statement says exactly what mine would have. It appears we have no choice but to leave this to the council to decide so I’m just going to let it lay for now. Tom wants to discuss internally this morning – he may have a stronger position when we get done. Thanks, Eric From: Clay Barnett [mailto:cbarnett@addisontx.gov] Sent: Friday, February 25, 2011 6:07 PM To: Nancy Cline; Lea Dunn; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; Nick Jacob; Tom Lamberth; Eric T. Little; 'Bruce Dunne'; 'K Power' Cc: Ext_mail John Hill Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Vitruvian Team, Attached is a draft of the council agenda item. Although I am reluctant to recommend the project to CPS Civil, I do not know if we have the basis needed to award the job to the next low bidder. I have incorporated all of the results of our information gathering into the report. Please give me your thoughts. Thanks, Clay Barnett, P.E. Town Engineer Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, TX 75001-2818 Office: (972) 450-2857 From: Clay Barnett Sent: Friday, February 25, 2011 10:23 AM To: Nancy Cline; Lea Dunn; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; 'Nick Jacob (PJacob@udr.com)'; 'Tom Lamberth'; 'Eric Little (elittle@udr.com)'; 'Bruce Dunne'; 'K Power' Cc: John Hill (jhill@cowlesthompson.com) Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Vitruvian Team, Attached is an email from Randy Moravec regarding the financial statements provided by Civil CPS. I have also called all of the references provided by Civil CPS. I am awaiting to hear back from two of them. Here is a summary of the individuals I have spoken with thus far: Project 1: 1. Did a good Job. 2. Did not initially show up with a backhoe large enough to handle the job. Did eventually get the right equipment for the job and did complete on schedule. 3. No safety issues. 4. No problems on change orders. Project 2: 1. Did a good job. 2. No safety issues. 3. Finished on schedule. 4. Only problem was that the superintendant they sent did not speak English. Project 3: 1. Quality of work was great, but had a lot of problems on the administration side. They had particular issues in completing the large amount of paperwork associated with a Federally funded project. 2. Change Orders were a nightmare. Very difficult to reach a reasonable standard. 3. Finished 3 days ahead of schedule. 4. No safety issues. 5. Would work with again on projects not involving Federal funding. Project 4: 1. Did a good job on a project that involved a lot of coordination. 2. Company administration was difficult to work with. 3. They did have an instance in which the shoring they were using was inadequate. They were in a trench of greater than 10’ depth. The shoring was inadequately supported and street plates were used to extend the height of the shoring to the same height as the adjacent curb. The client shut the project down. It was resolved after a lot of heated discussion and required CPS Civil administration to come to the site to inspect and discuss the inadequacies of the shoring. 4. Change Orders were a little excessive compared to other contractors. They were able to negotiate some of the costs. 5. Would hire again, but recommended strict inspection. 6. “Not the best but certainly not the worst.” Please review this information and let me know if you have any questions or comments. Thanks, Clay Barnett, P.E. Town Engineer Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, TX 75001-2818 Office: (972) 450-2857 From: Clay Barnett Sent: Wednesday, February 23, 2011 6:10 PM To: Lea Dunn Cc: Nancy Cline; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; 'Nick Jacob (PJacob@udr.com)'; 'Tom Lamberth'; 'Eric Little (elittle@udr.com)'; 'Bruce Dunne' Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Lea, We do have an issue in which I am unsure if the low bidder is qualified to complete the project. I would like to set up a meeting on Friday with them and discuss their qualifications. Because the success of the contractor can effect the overall project, I would like for the Vitruvian Team to be present at the meeting. Once we determine a low bidder, I should be able to complete the captions. Thanks, Clay Barnett, P.E. Town Engineer Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, TX 75001-2818 Office: (972) 450-2857 From: Lea Dunn Sent: Wednesday, February 23, 2011 10:45 AM To: Clay Barnett Cc: Nancy Cline; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; 'Nick Jacob (PJacob@udr.com)'; 'Tom Lamberth'; 'Eric Little (elittle@udr.com)'; 'Bruce Dunne' Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Clay: Sounds great. Matt is taking the lead on this agenda and to be helpful to him, I’d appreciate it if you’d go ahead and at least enter the captions for the items in Novus. I know you don’t have all the attachments yet but having the captions will help Matt. Let me know if you have any questions. Thanks, Lea Lea Dunn Deputy City Manager 972-450-7037 ldunn@addisontx.gov From: Clay Barnett Sent: Wednesday, February 23, 2011 10:09 AM To: Lea Dunn Cc: Nancy Cline; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; 'Nick Jacob (PJacob@udr.com)'; 'Tom Lamberth'; 'Eric Little (elittle@udr.com)'; 'Bruce Dunne' Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Lea, I anticipate bringing it to council on March 8. Along with that we will have the construction management contract with UDR and an additional services contract with Kleinfelder. Additionally, we will be bringing Change Order #5 for the park and Change Order #1 for Vitruvian Way Extension as well as an agreement with AT&T. It will be six Vitruvian related items in total (seven if the plat is included). If you have any additional questions, please let me know. Thanks, Clay Barnett, P.E. Town Engineer Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, TX 75001-2818 Office: (972) 450-2857 From: Lea Dunn Sent: Wednesday, February 23, 2011 9:42 AM To: Clay Barnett; Nancy Cline; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; 'Nick Jacob (PJacob@udr.com)'; 'Tom Lamberth'; 'Eric Little (elittle@udr.com)'; 'Bruce Dunne' Subject: RE: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Clay: When do you plan on bringing the item to Council? Thanks, Lea Lea Dunn Deputy City Manager 972-450-7037 ldunn@addisontx.gov From: Clay Barnett Sent: Tuesday, February 22, 2011 7:47 PM To: Nancy Cline; Lea Dunn; Tom Forrest; Matt McCombs; 'Nick Jacob (PJacob@udr.com)'; 'Tom Lamberth'; 'Eric Little (elittle@udr.com)'; 'Bruce Dunne' Subject: Bid Tab for Vitruvian Park, Phase 2 Attached is the bid tabulation for Vitruvian Park Public Infrastructure, Phase 2 (Bella Lane). The only abnormality was that Jaske Construction failed to enter a price for mobilization. All other bids were correctly tabulated and I did not see any items that appeared to be excessive when compared to the other bidders. Please note that Item 72 will not be awarded. This will lower the bids by roughly $70-80k. We will be vetting the low bid submitted by CPS Civil. If you have any questions, please let me know. Thanks, Clay Barnett, P.E. Town Engineer Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, TX 75001-2818 Office: (972) 450-2857 ****************************************************************************************************************** This e-mail and any files or attachments transmitted with it contains Information that is confidential and privileged. This document may contain Protected Health Information (PHI) or other information that is intended only for the use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom it is addressed. If you are the intended recipient, further disclosures are prohibited without proper authorization. If you are not the intended recipient, any disclosure, copying, printing, or use of this information is strictly prohibited and possibly a violation of federal or state law and regulations. If you have received this information in error, please delete it and notify Hamid Khaleghipour at 972-450-2868 immediately. Thank you. ******************************************************************************************************************* 㿝俞忟濠翡迢㆒䠶ㇰ腤肄柶えᕄ茠￯￧࿩Ὺ⿫㿬俭鿴濯ﮟ㿯￸࿺漋爌日邶塔䈉㔀ﰰⶐ㠲︱ﴸﺿᅬßǯϿЏ?⼅缌伇弈漉缊ἓ鼌ൿຯ྿჏ᇟ⏯⑟佢昐楦♣⃰㤨ἱ⤰㐠ပ儕㜵ᗿᚯឿᣏ᧟᫯᳿ᴏ?漤㼟传弡漢༫輤0慢낃敲㩦㑰瓐瀠⼺眯逾愮ﵴ츀渠츮☀⽰㮣Ⱜ敐摬숷䅦̀Î肄䡻偙剅䱠义⁋Ἶⰿ♽䁽䆱爀⽳岐ㅦ畜[ἥ⸦㈦㼧䐨楔낅⁳交晥删㩯滰ﰨ⨕㬨♸撠捥㫵懐銄蔺컰㬐䔯틪⽭㍥㌴㰠偊ꁥ抖퀺၍㩲ば搢욱敤㫀㍰㌸灑큥槼㑧㫐 ⹰兰晰㩐鉰ⱐ瑠㵵忐ᕸဠ〲ㅟ灑牳뭣瀺쑎蕢䨲㡐敐ℕ⻠灪絧灑;ꅒ䝥刿♟柀䵮赠鉓ᔶ㨠漐祰Ŏ⾿個兟副卿㪏捰偦㨊橕ﱀ䎐䑂‷䘱㐮㤶ダ︸娷嚡坟塯ㅿ㉏摟彥ཆ獣鍡䟏☿➯﾿켨�⽎꽧漮缯뽣替㌏㒿烏㙏㟯㧿㨏?彯⽹ェཬὭ⽮㽯翿鑏长枏璿枟焟爏?澤カླྀ辌⽺㽻榔끈㣞ᅽ퀽ﮅ䆕镤細Î쁀偅獦T饅ᾆ賽⫁쾚�ンྟᾠꁏ闙ﲜ獠戰蕲峹氦ǎ㪒桔郥攠ⷎ⁾₃⁠摮醥¶ⰿ腐䩐纀怀똠慰䩨艠䫀璀偍…ႃ뚽数삥큚[䁜扴삂↘聊㽉纱䴑ꝲ﹠䵨屠䩀ꢀⲱ䵐 舐㿀鎥낖能ㆦ違⹤꒡擔捯ꝵ‒⁾뙿ꠀ뚵ﶠ䰐峀ꢰ䠁攎ㅠ您䪩倨䥈⳿꛰莁宐箐㿰ꦢ캎＀쁌낥ƨ냥ゃႦ膦憰⃼啵댱츒䄀ꮀ畤ま猨ꊥ腍⠰놴潴쁚罨犨ƥ䅃퀽聽ኬら潹恵㴠돐늵묕퀽䁰苠ᓀ暰큜냧綁潐屳뛑랡낖ꑯ拰킧֨낷邨뭵瀡膰뱡똠蔠穐䷿띣䵛ꣀ뢐뤯ꔵ뫢뀔㉢Îᑧꮰꪑ쇱イ膦垳쎱�ƥ₁傅끜닟뮡ꬩ멓腰拠ꆲꀽꯝ激恽뎩㇥ꡦ蔀`↫膦₁恍䃽恽쁊ꊥ㷭某灅捍띳꩗ﴐQꁛ都삥ᅡ솭䂅ჽ狾釁傁≕၍傁ᇈ膨ꕯ뺢蕡굠䡐ƃ삥뽋Ⴊ냅큜ꆦⰠ ﻁⴭﰔ啰䩑䅠좀茁㊬炋띫⺒ᄁತ퇿폿ꐏꀌ��󓰟缯㿝ᾡ㾍侎徏源鲕뼳”쮖侌꾔몕븑됯爟㖳膖⽲⁚祤绠俫퉲⼷ㅳ犑깘ᗮ`