, i !, I I Ii 􀁾􀀮􀀠 􀁾􀀮􀀠r.::. 􀁾.AJ:::)f)IsoN CITY l'vlANAGER'S DEPARTMENT • (214)450·1000' FAX (214) 960.1684 􀁾􀁾􀁉􀁊􀁉􀀧􀁬􀁜􀁩􀀡􀁉􀁴􀁪􀀮􀀧􀁦􀁦􀁬􀁡􀁾􀁩􀀺􀂣􀀧􀀺􀀿􀀠Pust Office Box 144 A,idisnn. Texas 75001-0144 5300 Bell Line. ROlld April 9, 1997 Mr. Otis Welch Federal Aviation Administration 2601 Meacham Blvd. Fort Worth, Texas 76137-4298 Re: Keller Springs Toll Tunnel Dear Otis: The Town of Addison is excited about the prospect of meeting community and airport needs by constructing the Keller Springs Tunnel under Addison Airport. In working to bring this project forward, we are trying to address the FAA's concerns related to the project and the positive impact to the airport. In reviewing your letter of December 18, 1996 it appears that we are approaching this from the position of surplus property. The Town does not believe that is the 'appropriate position, The property in question is not being disposed of, but is in fact still part ofa roadway system that serves the airport. However, I will attempt to address your questions/issues as follows: The Town of Addison must address the following: a. The land is no longer needed for aeronautical purposes: The Town ofAddison is proposing to replace the 3 acres ofland with 4 acres along the west side ofthe airport. This replacement will provide additional acreage expressly for airport use, thus making them no longer needed for aeronautical purposes. b. The airport is receiving fair market value for the property: The Texas Turnpike Authority (ITA) contracted with a professional appraiser to determine the fair market value ofthe property based on the State law pertaining to eminent domain taking. This appraisal valued the property at $129 million. The Town, with the help of its real estate professionals Pat Haggerty and Marlin Blake, MAl, reviewed the appraisal and we negotiated a settlement of$1.416 million for the affected property. It is our opinion that this settlement fairly compensates the Town/Airport for the taking. c. The Airport has an immediate need that can be accomplished using the sale proceedS: The proceeds ofthe sale will be invested in the following ways: 1. Purchase of4 acres of property to replace the 3 acres affected by the tunnel. Mr. Otis Welch April 9, 1997 Page Two 2. Compensate leasehold investors, as required by law. 3. Pay for expenses associated with protecting the airport's interests relating to the right-of-way take by the Texas Turnpike Authority. The expenses include legal fees, appraisal expenses, and engineering fees associated with evaluating the impact ofthe tunnel and restructuring our agreements with our tenants. In addition, the Town of Addison will supplement the TIA's funds to satisfy the affected participants and avoid litigation. The Town of Addison win need to formally request approval from the FAA for a release and sale. Your request should cover the following items: a. What agreements with the United States obligates the land? The Town of Addison has fee interest in the affected property. This properly was purchased with one of the following FAA grants 5-48-0063-01 or 5-48-863-02. b. What is requested? The Town of Addison respectfully requests that the FAA support the use of the properly affected by the tunnel to permit the construction of this necessary infrastructure project. This includes 127, I II square feet (2.918 acres) of road right-of· way and 195,683 square feet (4.492 acres) of subsurface easement. c. Why the release of obligation is requested? The runway creates a physical barrier to the efficient movement of vehicles and goods in, across, and around the airport. The Town has evaluated a number of proposals to mitigate the congestion created in the community. Part ofthe solution includes constructing a tunnel under the airport that will connect east and west sections of Keller Springs, an arterial roadway that goes from Preston Road (State Highway 289) across IH-35E to Coppell in the west. d. What facts and circumstances justify the request? This project will benefit the airport by providing for the more efficient movement of vehicles and goods in, across and around the airport. It will provide better access to the aviation property on the west side of the field. While a total of three acres of airport property will be affected by the tunnel, the Town proposes to replace it with approximately four acres. This will provide additional land for continued development. e. What requirements of state or local law should be considered in the language of an FAA issued document ifthe request is granted? We are not aware of any specific language required by local or state law. Mr. Otis Welch April 9, 1997 Page Three f. What property is involved? See attached maps and descriptions. g. How was the property acquired by the town ofAddison? The property was purchased by the Town ofAddison from the original developers of the airport with an FAA grant and the appropriate sponsor match. h. What is the present condition of the property and how is it used? The property consists ofa collection of hangar facilities. A total of 19 patio hangars, 23 Thangars, and 2 jet hangars are affected by the construction. Currently, there are 2 I aircraft in these facilities. It is our estimate that all but 5 to 10 of these aircraft can be placed in other T-hangers or patio hangars on the field and that there are multi-storage facilities available for the remainder without requiring investors to remove existing non-aviation uses from their hangars. i. How will the property be used? The property will be used to construct a tunnel under the runway that completes a missing link in Keller Springs Road, a major arterial roadway. j. What is the fair market value (FMV) of the property? It is our opinion that fair market value ofthe property and improvements are $1.416 million based on the appraisal/negotiated settlement with the Texas Turnpike Authority. k. What will be done with the proceeds from the property? The Town ofAddison will use tbe proceeds in the following ways: L To purchase 4 acres ofreplacement property. 2. To meet our obligations under the law to compensate the affected investors for their leasehold interest. 3. To pay for expenses that are not compensable under an eminent domain process associated with the taking by the TTA. These include professional services oflegal counsel, real estate professionals, and engineering and surveying expenses incurred to reconfigure ground leases. These proceeds will be supplemented with funds from the Town ofAddison to satisfy the affected participants and avoid litigation. 􀁾..." Mr. Otis Welch April 9, 1991 Page Four I. A comparison of the relative advantage or benefit to the airport from the sale of property as opposed to retention for rental income. After purchase of replacement property, the Town will actually have more leaseable property than before. It allows for more efficient use of the remaining hangars and provides an impetus for the redevelopment ofthe T-hangar areas to be more consistent with the airport master plan. m. Provide a scaled drawing showing all airport property and facilities currently obligated for airport purposes by agreements with tbe United States. Include tbe land appraisal for tbe land you request to be released. Attached is an airport layout pIan, an exhibit "A" and property appraisals, A revised exhibit will be provided when the replacement property is purchased. We appreciate your patience as we attempt to construct this important infrastructure project. As with most projects ofthis magnitude there is some impact to the adjacent properties. We believe our proposal fairly mitigates the affected properties, Please call John Baumgartner at 912/450-2871 if you have any questions or need additional information regarding our submittal. Sincerely, Ron Whitehead City Manager Attachments: 1, Airport layout plan 2. Exhibit "A" 3. Property appraisal cc: Charles Carroll 301; Raleigh Street· P.O. Box 190369 Dallas, Thxas 75219 Phone 2141522-6200 Fax 214/528·4826 February 22, 1996 Town of Addison P.O. Box 144 Addison, TX 75001 Attn: Mr. Ronald N. Whitehead City Manager RE: Purchase ofsurface right-of-way tract and temporary construction easements, and donation of a subsurface easement (all designated as Parcel 13-5) situated in the Addison Airport, in the Town ofAddison, Dallas County, Texas, being more particularly described as follows: By Purchase: A. Surface 􀁒􀁩􀁾􀁨􀁴􀀠of Wav: 130,107 square feet or 3.987 acres out of a called 365.34 acre tract as conveyed to the Town of Addison by deed recorded in Volume 77010, Page 1391, Deed Records, Dallas County, Texas, arId being out ofthe Wm. Lomax Survey, Abstract 792 and the E. Cook Survey, Abstract 326. B. Temporary Construction Easement No.1: 68,911 square feet or 1582 acres out of a called 365.34 acre tract as conveyed to the Town of Addison by deed recorded in Volume 77010, Page 1391, Deed Records, Dallas County, Texas, and being out of the Wm. Lomax Survey, Abstract 792 and the E. Cook Survey, Abstract 326. C. Temporary Construction Easement No.2: 3,400 square feet or 0.078 acres out of a called 365.34 acre tract as conveyed to the Town ofAddison by deed recorded in Volume 77010, Page 1391, Deed Records, Dallas County, Texas, and being out of the Wm. Lomax Survey, Abstract 792 arId the E. Cook Survey, Abstract 326. D. Temporary Construction Easement No.3: 4,902 square feet or 0.113 acres out of a called 365.34 acre tract as conveyed to the Town ofAddison by deed recorded in Volume 77010, Page 1391, Deed Records, Dallas County, Texas, and being out of the Wm. Lomax Survey, Abstract 792 arId the E. Cook Survey, Abstract 326. \ MEllliER$; JERI:: \t TIlO;\lPSO:'1.JR., CIBIR.'I1.\S. DALLAS .. 􀁌􀁕􀁔􀁴􀁬􀁅􀁒􀁇􀀮􀁊􀁏􀁾􀁅􀁓􀀬􀁊􀁒􀀮􀀠ViCE 􀁃􀁈􀀮􀁜􀁉􀁒􀁾􀁉􀀮􀁜 􀁾􀀮􀀠OORPl'SCfJRlSTI 􀁽􀀮􀁾􀁓􀁅􀀠S. WYN;"'E, AUSTIX .. MICll'.El \'. CIIOLl, 􀀱􀁉􀀰􀁕􀁓􀀱􀀧􀁏􀁾􀀠.. D.WID M, 􀁬􀀮􀁜􀀮􀁾􀁮􀁙􀀮􀀠IHLLAS .. 􀁬􀁏􀁒􀁒􀁾􀁉􀁾􀁅􀀠PERR\1L\S. ODESS.\ 􀁔􀁏􀁾􀁾􀁴􀁜􀁓􀀠CAROE;'A S,JR., E1. PASO .. D.\\'ID E. BERX$EX, 8t:.\uMO:YT .. tEAHR.W\\,ROTES. fAlItVIE\f • RAVL .\. BESTt:IRO. JR.• 􀁂􀁒􀁏􀁕􀁾􀀧􀁓􀁜􀀧􀀱􀁌􀁌􀁅􀀠\ '.i'X£ A. Kt;:;SEDi'. 􀁮􀁯􀁵􀁳􀀱􀀧􀁏􀁾􀀠• PltlLIP 􀁢􀀱􀀰􀀺􀀧􀀺􀁩􀁇􀁏􀁍􀁅􀁒􀁾􀀺􀀠D.UL\5 .. j.\,\1E5 w: 􀁇􀁒􀁬􀁦􀁦􀁬􀁾􀀮􀀠EXECVTI\'E D1RI:CTOR • J1MMIE G, 􀁎􀁅􀁖􀀻􀁔􀁏􀁾􀀬􀀠SECRETARY • 􀁳􀀮􀁬􀁲􀀵􀀮􀁜􀁾􀀠,\. BOSE, TRF.,\Sl;ItER \ AN AGENCY OF THE STATE OF TEXAS Mr. Ronald N. Whitehead Town of Addison February 22,1996 Page 2 of3 E. Permanent Subsurface Easement: 195,683 square feet or 4.492 acres out ofa called 365.34 acre tract as conveyed to the Town ofAddison by deed recorded in Volume 77010, Page 1391, Deed Records, Dallas County, Texas, and being out ofthe Wm. Lomax Survey, Abstract 792 and the E. Cook Survey, Abstract 326. Ladies and Gentlemen: The Texas Turnpike Authority (the "Authority") must obtain a portion ofthe Town ofAddison's (the "City") property (parcel 13-5) within the Addison Airport boundaries required for construction ofthe Addison Airport Toll Tuunel Project (the "Tuunel"). Two copies each ofthe legal description and plat of each of the above-referenced property interests to be acquired are being provided as attachments. On the'basis of appraisals made by a qualified appraiser, the Authority is hereby offering the City $1,291,059 for the property required for the Tuunel. This amount is based on the fair market value for the following: (i) 130,107 square feet ofsurface easement for road right-of-way, valued as iffee title to the property were being acquired, and (ii) three temporary construction easements of 68,911 square feet, 3,400 square feet and 4,902 square feet, each, plus the current value of any improvements in the part taken, as well as any other damages to the remaining property. Based upon prior discussions between the City and the Authority, it is the Authority's understanding that the City intends to donate approximately 195,683 square feet ofsubsurface area through which the Tunnel will be constructed. Consequently, the above offer excludes auy compensation for the acquisition of subsurface area. The enclosed plats do not include any encumbrances on the portion ofthe Addison Airport property to be acquired other than certain airplane hangers and related buildings, plus a few parking spaces in the right-of-way to be acquired from the premises currently occupied by Bill White's Ultimate Sports Bar and the Concourse Plaza office. If you you find there are additional encumbrances to the property, we will need to investigate those jointly to determine ifthe Authority has an obligation to relocate or compensate the City for such additional encumbrances. As we mentioned to the City staff during our meeting ofNovember 28, 1995, it is the policy ofthe Authority, when purchaj)ing right-of-way or any other property interests, that the owner ofthe land must satisfy such obligations as it may have to any lessees, optionees, mortgagees, or others who may own an interest in the land or improvements. Furthermore, we understand that the City is Mr. Ronald N. Whitehead Town ofAddison February 22, 1996 Page 3 of3 prepared to negotiate with Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc., and any other leasehold owner whose leasehold interests (or a portion thereof) will be acquired. In that regard, we intend to meet with the City's staff to review at 10:00 a.m. on March 1, 1996, the appraisals that have been prepared for acquisition ofthe above-described property, If a sales agreement is executed between the City and the Authority, the Authority will pay all recording fees and title insurance costs. After the City's staff has had an opportunity to meet with the Authority's staff to review the appraisal reports, ifthe City desires to accept this offer, please advise us as soon as possible so that a sales agreement can be drawn, Funds are available to purchase the property and a closing is possible within thirty days after execution ofthe sales agreement, provided any liens and judgments on the property required are released. Yours very truly, James W. Griffin, P.E. xecutive Director Enclosures nig MARLIN M. BLAKE & ASSOCIATES, INC. REAL ESTATE APPRAISERS & CONSULTANTS FOREST ASRAMS PLACE SOUTH 9304 FOREST LANE, SUITE 120 • DALLAS. TEXAS 75243 TEL. (214) 340-8510 FAX (214) 553-1650 December 12, 1996 Town of Addison 16801 Westgrove Drive Addison, Texas 75001-0144 ATI'N: Mr. John Baumgartner, P. E. Director of Public Works Re: Appraisal Report Proposed Tunnel Conneetor for KeHer Springs Road H & S Ventures Parcels J, K & L Dear Mr. Baumgartner: In accordance with your request I have reviewed the documents relating to the captioned parceL I would propose to prepare an appraisal report on the property for a fee not to exceed $2,200. I understand that time is of the essence and I would attempt to complete the report on or before December 31, 19%. It is difficult at this time of the year to reliably comIrm market data for inclusion in the analysis. However, I will proceed diligently in order to satisfy your time constraints. I appreciate the opportnnity to submit this proposal and hope to be of service to you in this matter. Sincerely, 􀁍􀁾􀁊􀀿􀀿􀀦􀁌􀀠Marlin M. Blake, SRA P.2 12-20-1996 10,52AM FROM MARLIN M. BLAKE & ASSOCIATES. INC. REAl. eSTA.Te APPRAISERS & CON$ULTANTS FOREST ABRAMS PLACe: SOUTH 􀀹􀁾􀀰􀀴􀀠FOREST LANe. Sum; 120 • DALLAS. TeXAS 75243 TEL. (214) 340-6510 FAX (214) 553-1650 December n,1996 Town of Addison 161101 Wmgrove Drive Addison, Teus 75001-0144 ATIN: Ml'.lo1m Baumgsrhltr',P•.E•. Di:leetor of Public Works Re: Appraisal Report Proposed T'IDlIlei CODDeetor fill' Keller Springs Road B '" S Veatares Pareda J, K '" L Dear Mr. BaWlllartDer: In aec0r4aJlce with yOIII' request I bave reviewed the doc:umem:s nlatiDg to the captioned parcd. I would propose to prepare an appraisal report Oil the propet:ty for a fee not hi exceed Sl,lOO. I undentand that time is vt the eutac:e aad I would aucmpt to complete the report 08 or before December 31, 1996. Itis difficult at this time of the year to reliably coDl'irm 'IlW'ket datil for inehlsion in the aaaiysis. However, I will proceed diligeady in order to JatiJfy your time eollStraints. J appreciate the opportunity to sa.bmit this proponl 8Jld hope to be or.ervice to you in this matter. 􀁊􀁮􀁾nt 1$0_1..... MarIiJl M. Blake, SRA Texas Turnpike 􀁁􀁵􀁴􀁨􀁯􀁲􀁩􀁾􀁹􀀠Fonn 200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number ___-'______ Address Unallocated portions of right of wav and tcm[l9mry constmction easements taken Address______________Owner Citv ofAddison Occupant's Name Addision Municipal Aimort Whole Taking ____ PartiaI Taking X Purpose ofthe Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subject property as of 12/20/95. It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein wi!! be used for settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered for sale by one who desires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration aU of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation In my opinion the compensation due as a result ofthis taking is: Owner $,_______ Leasehold Interest "'________ Total $ 120.121. Appraiser's Certificate I hereby certif'y that the opinion of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fcc is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notif'y the Authority of such interest or interests. 􀁵􀁾􀁾􀀯􀁾􀁴􀀨Appraiser Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-Wa Fonn 200la Page 2 A TIACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No. Local Address,__________________ Date Taken,__________ Taken by ________________ 1. Point from which taken _______________ Looking _______ 2. Point from which takenc--___________-,..__ Lookin.;;,.g_______ Fonn 200Ia Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description Abstract 792, Addision Municipal Airport Dimensions: Right ofway taken -=.c36"",,,,,87,,,,6,--_sq.ft, .8466 Acres Location (Urban): Street & No. _________---:_____on,________,side between -:_--,,-______________ and _____________streets. (Rural): _____-::--:-:::--:-:--__________________ 􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁟􀀺􀁟􀁟􀀽􀁟􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀽􀀭􀁾� �􀁾􀁌􀁍􀁤􀁇􀁲􀁍􀁴􀁓􀁵􀁾􀁥􀁹􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀺􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀭􀀺􀁟􀁟􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀂭Neighborhood or Area Analysis: TI,e Neighborhood is a commercial Md industrial area, having restaurant, neighborhood 􀁳􀁥􀁾􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀬􀀠office, office showroom and warehouse facilities, A major asset in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation, The subject is located on Airport property. Highest and Best Use and Zoning of Subject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial -3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY NIA Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: ft. @$ per square fool.. ...... """".",,$:--__ Parking Lot: per ft "".""""".. "".. """".....,"'$__--:: Total Reproduction, " .. " ""c.. "".. "","""""."".........",."""""....... " ... """.""......... ".",,$___ Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration ... "."""""... " .. ,,, .. ,, .."".""."... " .. "".""""."... " $___ Functional Obsolescence .. """,..""""......"" """.""".. " ... "." ."""."",,"'$___ Economic Obsolcsscencc " ..... , ..."".."".....".".............. ,,,.,,,,.,, .. ""......$__---, Total Depreciation .................. " ... " .......... " ......................... " ... " .................. " .......... $___-: Value Building Contributes to Whole Property ..... "".."""""""."."""".".. "." ."".""""".""..",,$____ Garages: ft. @$ per ft .... " ..................... ......................... ".$___ Less Depreciation ................................... " ............................................................ $ Other (Detail) ....... " ................. ,." ... " ......................... " ......... , ........................... " ... ".$___ Less Depreciation ... " ............... , ....... ".".. " ..... " .. " ....... , ... "" .................... ....... , ...... $ $,____ $____ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $,---::--:-" Fencing $,___􀁾􀀠Walks $ , Drives $ .,'" ... ""... " .......... """""........"".""".... " ........... " .... $____ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property """ .. ""............ " ................ ", .............. ,"'$____ LAND ... " ........ "'-$____per ........................ " .. , ................ "",,...... "., ........................ ,$ == ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH. ......................... ""."....... " .. "".................... ".$,___ Comment on Depreciation Factors: Mi..􀁾􀁅􀁔􀁄􀁁􀁔􀁁􀁁􀁐􀁐􀁒􀁏􀁁􀁃􀁈􀁗􀁈􀁏􀁌􀁅􀁐􀁒􀁏􀀮􀀠ATI (Land Comparables) Date._________Purchase Price of SUbject Property $----------Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information of Comparable Properties Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $ ... 1-'.:10"",,,,62,,,,8,,-,____ Fonn 2001a Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY N/A JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION:_________ Estimated remaining economic life ofimprovements--:-_________________ Stabilized Gross Income............................................$,___ Vacancy % ............................................ ___ Effective Gross Income...... ; .................................... ............................................................... .$,____ Taxes: City ........................................................................ $___ State & County ...................... ................................. $___ Miscellaneous (School, etc.)....................................$.___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage......................................$___ Miscellaneous.........................................................$,___ Annual Deferred Maintenance....................................$___ Management %. .......................................$, ___ Operating Expenses .................................................. $,___ Other Expenses ...............................$,___ Total Expenses before Depreciation ................................ ........................................................ .$ Nct Income to Property ........................................................................................................... $____ Less Income Attributable to (Land)............................ $ @% ................... $____ Income Attributable to (Improvements) ............................................................. .....................$____ Income Capitalized @% ( % Interest % for Recapture ofCapital) .... $____ (Land) (Improvements) ............................................................................. ............................$ ESTIMATED VALUE BY CAPITALIZATION APPROACH ..............................................,""$___ ADDmONAL APPRAISAL INFORMATION Fonn 200la Page 6 FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE OF VfHOLE PROPERTY Correlaton ofApproaches to Value SeePage 6A Estimated Value ofWhole Property Owner $ Leasehold $_____ .................................... ................... $ ____ 6A CORRELATION The City of Addison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres of land. Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement terminates on December 31, 2000. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value of the subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units of comparison derived from sales ofsimIlar properties in the marketplace. Those units ofcomparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative ofthe market estimate of value for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis of the income stream of the property and comparison ofthat income stream with income streams of similar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate ofvalue. The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal of substitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value ofthe site, the reproduction cost ofthe improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue. The market approach has been used to estimate the value of the land. Sale #1 is located One block south of the subject and east ofAddison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north of the subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west ofthe subject and on the west side ofAddison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property. The market approach is used to determine the value ofthe land and it is the most reliable indicator of the value of the subject. These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity ofAddison Airport used for commercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of$3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market value ofthe land before the taking for the land taken, and for the land value after the taking. This report values the unallocated portion ofthe property taken from the City ofAddison contained in the Addision Municipal Airport that has not been considered as being related to a particular hanger or structure which has been valued previously with the tunnel project. Of the 130, 107 square feet taken for right of way, 36,876 square feet are unallocated. Ofthe 77,213 square fuet fuet taken under the temporary construction easement, 15,068 square feet are unallocated. ,. At $3. multiplied times 36,876 square feet, the fair market value of unallocated land taken for right ofway equals $110,628. The temporary construction easement will be needed for two years. That compensation for the unallocated portion ofthe temporary construction easement will be equal to 10.5% ofthe fair market value ofthe land for that'period or $9,493. (15,068 sq.ft. x $3. x 10.5% x 2 yrs "" $9,492.84). i Tthe unallocated portions ofthe property taken for right ofway and for the construction easement cause no damage to the remaining property. Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Right ofWay Taken $110,628. Construction Easement 9,493. Taken Total Just Compensation $120,121. Fonn 200la Page 7 􀁄􀁁􀁔􀁁􀁏􀁎􀁐􀁁􀁒􀁔􀁾􀁔􀁾􀁇􀀠Legal Description Part Taken Abstract 792, Addison Municipal AiIllort Dimensions: Right ofway taken 36.876 sq.ft. .8466 Acres WHOLE PROPERlY: The market value ofthe whole property is .................$ 110,628. PART TAKEN: The market value of the fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is:.................................................. , ..................................... $110,628. (I) REMAINING PROPERlY: The market value ofthe remiander inunediately before the taking is: ................... , .......................................... $ (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder inunediately after the taking is: ...................................$ (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany .. , ................................... ",....................... ,., ................................ $____ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, jfany.............. " .................... , ....................................... , ..􀀤􀀬􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀁾􀀭􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀭􀁟􀀠 TOTAL COMPENSATION ............................................................................... $I 10,628. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of Part Taken ::--c:---=--:-:---------------------Remainder Before Taking -:-:-:_-::-___:-:-::-;-__________ Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected __. Contributory Remainder Remainder Value of Part Taken Before After Improvements Taking Taking RIGIITOFWAY LAND-36,876 SQ.FT. $110,628. TOTAL AS A UNIT CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + $110,628. (1) 9,493. $120,121. $ -0(2) $ -0(3) ==== Explain difference, if any, between Remainder Before and After Taking (If extra space needed, use attachment.) Form 200la Page 8 #1 CVlv1PARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMEl'I, 􀁾􀀭􀀭􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀼􀀮􀀠-------= Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Invi'!stmentLtd. Grantee Addison 􀁌􀁴􀀮􀀢􀀬􀁤􀀮􀁾􀁟􀁾􀀮_____ Dated_-,-,l􀀰􀀡􀀡􀀮􀁣􀀯􀀳􀀢􀀢􀀱􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀯􀀹􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀴􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀭􀁟􀁾____ Recorded in Volume29c:t46.2!.\101.--______ Page 3570 Local Address 4901 Airport Parkwav Legal 􀁄􀁥􀁳􀁣􀁲􀁩􀁰􀁴􀁩􀁯􀁮􀁾􀀺􀁬􀁊􀀻􀁊􀁳􀁴� �􀀠482. Tract 30. Addison. TX Actual 􀁐􀁮􀁣􀁥􀁾􀁓􀀡􀀮􀀻􀀷􀀴􀀺􀀡􀀻􀁯􀀲􀀬􀀢􀀭􀀮􀀬􀀢􀁏􀁏􀀢􀀬􀁏􀀬􀀢􀀭􀀮__________Verified 􀁗􀁩􀁴􀁨􀀬􀀭􀀢􀁋􀀢􀀢􀁥􀀢􀀬􀁮􀁾􀁴H'-'!!0lllpe'--__________ Conditions of Sale_Cas."h'--__________________ RenrnlDaw__________________________________________ Land Size 5.4963 Acr"'es'-___ Unit Price: As Improved______.; Unimproved-'$"'3c-.l"'O'-___ Street__----"C"'u"'r b'-.&",·ccGu"""lt"'e"r______________-_. ______ Utilities_____ Improvments None at sal,...e_________________________________ Size and Description__-:-:::--:-:-__---:-􀁾􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀻􀀠---,:--:-';- --::--:-----:--:"7--:--______ Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance ofthe tract ofwhich Condition and Desirability-.lliiswi"s,!;awp..a"'rt""._______________________ ;-. Current UseJed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best Use Commercial Date Inspected 7/15/95 Zoning Comrnercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent information Fonn 200la Page 8 #2 􀁾􀁾􀀷􀁾_____􀁾􀀭􀁶􀀬􀁶􀁊􀁌􀁲􀁾􀀮􀁾􀀬􀁾􀁾􀁓􀁁􀁌􀁅􀁓􀁄􀁁􀁊􀀨􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁕􀁐􀀮􀁊􀁾􀁌􀁅􀁪􀁍􀁅􀁴􀁱􀀽􀀠 Sales Parties: Gramor M& F Development Co.. Inc. Grantee Manufacturing Dated 3/2 1/95 Recorded in Volume 9:><.:-O"'S"'5'-______ Page -'4"'6""3'--__ Lecal Address 4500 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description West V, _Tract 13 Sunhelt Business Park Addition_ AddisQnl._..;T"'X"-_______ Actual Price.-->!$",1",2)",·􀀮􀀧􀀢􀀢􀁏􀀢􀁏􀁏􀀢􀀢􀀮􀁾_______Verified With George Roddv.._________ Conditions ofSale-'C"'a"'sh"-____________________________ Rental Datc________________________________ Land Size 1.0382 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____; Unimproved $2.76 Street Concrete Ctirh & Gutter Utilities------'A"'l!!.l___ Improvments None at Sa"'le'-____________________________ Size and Description Level. readv for development Condition and Desirability___ Current Use_-'U"'n"'im=p"ro"'v"'ed"-________ Highest and Best Use Ligllt Industrial & ColTUl1ercial Date Inspected_7"-/""15,,,'",,-9,,,S),,--________ Zoning Commercial-] Use reverse side for other pertinent 􀁩􀁮􀁦􀁯􀁲􀁭􀁡􀁴􀁩􀁯􀁮􀁾_________-;-___-c;-.,,-__ ____ 􀁡􀁡􀀬􀀨􀀦􀁉􀁉􀁙􀁾􀁾􀀠. Form 200la Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT Sales Parties: Grantor _C"'h"'aiC\il>!.\.,.C"'h"'in"--__________ Grantee 􀁾􀁁􀀢􀀢􀁅􀀢􀀢􀁒􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀭______ Dated 4114/95 Recorded in Volume-<:9"'50"-7r.::;4'--_____ Page -,6""6,,,8__ Local Address 2030 Chenault. Carrollton, TX Legal Description Abstract 923. Tract 20 Actual Price-"!$""5""30"'."'SO"'O"".________Verified With Pat Hagl!ertv Conditions ofSale--"C"'as""h"-___________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁾􀀬􀀢_______________________________ Land Size 4.0592 Acres Unit Price: As Improved,_____; Unimproved $3,00 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter Utilities-"-A"'ll'--___ Improvrnents None at Sale Size and Description_____________________________ Condition and Desirability__________________________ _ Current Use Warehouse under constmciton Highest and Best 􀁕􀁳􀁥􀀭􀀧􀁃􀁾􀁯􀀢􀀧􀁭􀁭􀀢􀀢􀀧􀁥􀀢􀀧􀁲􀀢􀀧􀁣􀀮􀀡􀂣􀁩􀁡􀀢􀀧􀁬_______ Date Inspected--'I"'O"I2"'2"-'/9"'5'--_______ Zoning Commercial-j Use reverse side for other pertinent information _____________________ 􀀦􀁵􀀴􀁤􀀯􀁾􀁤􀀠 Texas Turnpike Authority Fonn200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number-'P"a"'rc"'e"-I..<.A'-______ Address 4700 Block Keller Springs Rd .. Addison Texas Ovmer_____________ Address_____________ Occupant's Name City of Addison Whole Takin,,,,g___Partial Takin,e.g_X,,-,-_ Purpose of the Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subjeet property as of 12120/95. It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in cO!U1ection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the ovmer of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein will be used for settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered for sale by one who desires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation In my opinion the compensation due as a result of this taking is: Ovmer 􀁾________ Leasehold Interest 􀁾_______ Total $ 15.63l. Appraiser'S Certificate I hereby certifY that the opnuon of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither r nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to tbe property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notifY the Authority of such interest or interests. Appraiser Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-W Form 200 I a Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No,________ Local Address 4700 Block Keller Springs Road, Date Taken ___""9,,-,'7""/9,,,S,--Taken by Charles (Eo) Miller I. Point from wllicll taken Adjacent PropertY Looking _---'\\"""'es"'t____ Fonn 200 I a Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description Abstract 326, Addison Municipal Airport Dimensions: feet x ______feet-4.674 sq,ft..1078 Acres Location (Urban): Street & No. _________-:-____on_______-'side between-::::_-::-_____________and ____________streets. 􀁾􀁵􀁾􀀩􀀺________􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭__-----------􀁾􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀽􀀺􀁟� �􀀭􀀭􀀻􀁟􀁟􀀺􀁟􀁟􀀺􀁟􀁟􀀺􀀺􀀽􀁟􀁌􀁡􀁮􀁤􀀠Grant Survey ___"....,.__-:-----:--:-__--.,._____ Neighborhood or Area Analysis: The Neighborhood is a commercial and industrial area, having restaurant, neighborhcod service, office, office showroom and warehouse facilities. A major asset in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation. The subject is located on Airport property. Highest and Best Use and Zoning ofSubject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial-3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: ft. @$ per square foot.. .... " .............. $_--.,.=-_ Parking Lot: $1.15 per square ft. 225 sq.ft .................. $ 259. Total Reproduction .................. " ........ ''''''''''''''''............. ....................................... $ 259. Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration ........................................................................ $ ____ Functional Obsolescence .................................................................... 0'$____ Economic Obsolescence ..................................................................... $___-::::Total Depreciation ................................................................................................... $ ___. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property ................... ....................................................... $ 259. Garages: ft. @$ per fi.......................................................$___ Less Depreciation .................................... ............................................................. $ $'--__ Other (Detail) ... Fencing@$6/Iinearfoot x 215.ft ...... "........................................."..$ 1,290. Less Depreciation ....... "........................................................................................$ $ 1.290. Depreciated Value: Landscaping $,__-::-:-" Fencing $,___􀁾􀀬􀀠Walks $ , Drives $ ..............................................................................$,____ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property ..................................................... ....... $ 1,549. LAND ............ .4,694 square feet ",$3",.",,00,,-__per.sq.ft ................................................... $14,082. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH. ....................... ............................................... $15.631. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Texas Turnpike Authority Dallas North Tollway Fonn 200 la Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY (Land Comparables) Date_________Purchase Price of Subject Property $,-------------Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Tenus or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information of Comparable Properties SALE NO, 2 3 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10/31194 Hope InY(. Ltd. Addison. Ltd. 3/21195 M&F Development Co Diverseo Mann 04/17[95 Chaiu Chin AER SALE CONFIRMED WITH ADDRESS & LOCATION IN RELATION TO SUBJECT Kent HOr;!e 490 I Airport Pkwy, 344.47' E Addison Rd I Blk South George Roddy 4500 blk Sunbelt, Approx. 667' W. of Addison Rd 5 blks N. Pat Haggerty 2030 Chenault@Earhart southeast comer ACTUAL SALE PRICE $742.000. $125.000. $530500, CONDITIONS OF SALE Cash Cash Cash ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE $3.10 $2.76 $3.00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA CURRENT USAGE Federal Express Distribution Faeilitv Unimproved Warehouse under Construction HIGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Commercial Commercial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale None at sale None at sale Correlation of Comparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $....1""4",.0",,82,,,.___ i Form 200la Page 5 N/A INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION: _________ Estimated remaining economic life ofimprovements--=_________________ Stabilized Gross Income............................................$,___ Vacancy % ............................................ ___ Effective Gross Income............................................. ..............................................................$____ Taxes: City........................................................................$:--__ State & County........................... ............................$:___ Miscellaneous (School, etc.) .................................... $.___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage......................................$___ Miscellaneous.........................................................$___ Annual Deferred Maintenance .................................... $___ Management % ...................................... $.___ Operating Expenses ...................................................$,___ Other Expenses ...............................$.___ Total Expenses before Depreciation .............. , ....................... , ................................... , ............. $ . ===== Net Income to Property ...................................................................................... ..................... $____ Less Income Attributable to (Land)............................. $.____ @__% ..................... $____ Income Attributable to (Improvements) ............................. ......................................................$,____ Income Capitalized@:___% 􀀨􀁾__% Interest,___% for Recaptnre ofCapital) ....... $____ (Land) (Improvements) ....... : .................... ............................................................................... $ ESTIMATED VALUE BY CAPITALIZATION APPROACH ...............................................""'$___ ADDmONAL APPRAISAL INFORMATION Form 2001a Page 6 FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE OF\VHOLEPROPERTY Correlaton ofApproaches to Value See6A Estimated Value ofWhole Property Owner $ Leasehold "'_____........................................... ............$,____ 6A CORRELATION The City of Addison owns Aodison Airport, which comprises approxunately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport of Texas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement terminates on December 31,2000. Several ground leases extend beyond that date. This property is under a ground lease with an original term of forty years, as of November I, 1995. Twenty three (23) years, three (3) months remain on the lease. For purposes of this report, it is assumed that the property is owned and operated by the fee owner. The fair market value estimated herein does not attempt to determine the value of the leased fee, the sublease position (sandwich position) of the airport management or the leasehold estate created by the lease for the tenant currently in possession of the property. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value of the subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units of comparison derived from sales of similar properties in the marketplace. Those units of comparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative of the market estimate of value for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis ofthe income stream ofthe property and comparison of that income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate of value. The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal ofsubstitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value of the site, the reproduction cost of the improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue. The market approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land. Sale # 1 is located one block south ofthe subject and east ofAddison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north of the subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west of the subject and on the west side of Addison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property. These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity ofAddison Airport used for commercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value ofS3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market value of the land before the the taking and for the land taken. At $3.00 per square foot the fair market value ofthe land is taken for right ofway equals $14,082. (4,694 sq.ft. x $3), The cost approach is the most reliable indicator ofvalue ofthe subject. There is no damage to the remaining property. 1: _:: . ... Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvement Taken $ 1,549. Right ofWay Taken 14,082. Total Just Compensation $15,631. .. Fonn 2001a Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKING Legal Description Part Taken _________________________ Dimensions x = 4,694 Sq.Ft. .1078 Acres WHOLE PROPER1Y: The market value of the whole property is ................. $ 15.631. PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is:........................................................................................ $15,631. (I) REMAINING PROPER1Y: The market value ofthe remiander immediately before the taking is:.............................................................. $ (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value of the remainder immediately after the taking is:...................................$ (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany ...................................................................................................􀀤􀀮􀁟􀁾 􀀭􀁏􀁣􀀮􀀭__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, if any ............................................................................... 􀀤􀀧􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀲􀀭􀀰􀁾􀀭􀀭􀁟􀀠 TOTAL COMPENSATION .......................... ..................................................... $15,631. APPRAISALS OF P ART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of Part Taken=-:;---=-:--;-______􀁾_____________ Remainder Before Taking --:-:-;-_.,.--__ -::7C:-:----------Remainder after taking considering the use to which the parttaken is to be subjected____________________ Contributory Value of Improvements Part Taken Remainder Before Taking Remainder After Taking Paving 2,256 sf@$1.15 $ 259. 1.290. TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS 1,549. LAND 4,694 SF@$3. 14.082. -0-0, TOTAL AS A UNIT $15,631. (1) -0(2) -0(3) Fonn 200la Page & #1 ( IlPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMI Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd. Grantee Addison Ltd. Dated 1013lJ.i/9"'4______Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀮􀁾􀀹􀁣􀀺􀀡􀀴􀀢􀀢􀀧􀀲􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀬􀀱 􀁏􀀬􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁟􀁾____ Page 3570 Local Address 4901 Airport Parkway Legal Description Abst 482. Tract 30. Addison. TX Actual Price-"$.,.74"'2"".""0"-00"'._________Verified With-EK"e"lnl..t􀁈􀁾􀁯􀁪􀀬􀁬􀁰� �􀀬􀀬􀀭__________ Conditions ofSale-'C"'a"'sh"-_____________________________ Rental Date_______________________________ Land Size 5.4963 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____; Unimproved..,,$,.,,3"'.1'- \0'--__ Street.__􀁾􀁃􀀼􀀮􀀡􀀮􀁵􀁬􀁌􀁲􀁢􀁬􀁌􀂣􀀡􀀦􀁾􀁇􀀡􀁤􀀱􀀡􀁵􀁴􀁴􀁬􀁬􀁥􀀢􀀧􀁲􀁾_______________ Utilities________ Improvments None at sale Size and Description Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance of the tract of which Condition and Desirability this is a part. Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best Use_-"C"o."nun"""e"'r""ci"'al'--_______ Date Inspected 7115/9S.. _________ Zoning Commercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent infonnation, __________.-____7'-;,t-__ {»v4f}?t l£!t,' Form 200la Page 8 112 Sales Parties: Grimtor M& F 􀁄􀁥􀁶􀁥􀁬􀁯􀁪􀀩􀁭􀀢􀀢􀀬􀁥􀁮􀀢􀀬􀁴􀀬􀀭􀀬􀁃􀀢􀁯􀀢􀀬􀀬􀁾􀀬",In"c,,-,_____ Grantee Manufacturing Daled 3121195 Recorded in Volume,--29"'Sj£0,"'"S'--____ __ Page ""4"'6""3'--__ Local Address 4500 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description West Y, Tract 13 Sunbelt Business Park Addition, Addison, TX Actual Price $125,000, Verified With George Roddy__________ Conditions ofSale,...."C"'a"'s,..h____________________________ Rental Dale_______________________________ Land Size_LO""3,,8"'2'-'-A"'c""r""es'--___􀁾__ Unit Price: As Improved,_____: Unimproved $2,76 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter Utilities,--,AlCY!,.l___ Improvments None at Sale Size and Description LeveL ready for development Condition and Desirability___________ ________________ Current Use,_-"U"'n!iin,..ljl""r"'o"'ve"'d'--_______ Highest and Best Use Light Industrial & Commercial Date Inspected_7!LJ...,15t.b..>&"->G"' u"tt"'e"'r________________ Utilities__-----Improvments_NQne..l'!Uill",... ____________________________ 􀁓􀁾􀁥􀁡􀁮􀁤􀁄􀁥􀁬􀀻􀁣􀁲􀁩􀁰􀁴􀁫􀀩􀁮____________________________ Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance of the tract of which Condition and 􀁄􀁥􀁳􀁩􀁲􀁡􀁢􀁩􀁬􀁩􀁴􀁹􀁟􀁴􀀢􀀭􀁨􀀢􀀧􀁩􀁳􀀧􀀭􀀢􀀧􀁩􀁳􀀧􀀭􀀧􀁡􀁕􀀢􀁰􀁡􀀢􀀧􀁲􀁴􀀢􀀮􀁾_______________________ Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best u",______________ Date Inspected 7115/95 􀁚􀁯􀁮􀁩􀁮􀀱􀀤􀀮􀁧􀁾􀁃􀀢􀀢􀁯􀁭􀀬􀀡􀁩􀁬􀁬􀀡􀁭􀀧􀁟􀀧􀁥􀁾􀁲􀀢􀀧􀁣􀀡􀀡􀀡􀁩􀁡􀀡􀀡􀀮􀀺􀁉􀀭􀁃􀀡􀀱__________ Use reverse side for other pertinent information __________________ : ,". Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority Form 200 I a Page 8 112 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT Sales Parties: Grantor United States of America Grantee Metroport Realtv Corp, Dated 7/19/95 Recorded in Volume--"9"'5...1L39"-______ Page -""''''-'L__ Local Address Extension of Frank Luke Legal Description A-792 Part of Addison Airport Actual Price--"$...13".,S"",O",0,,,0,,-,________Verified With George Roddy Conditions of Sale-'C"'n"'sh"-___________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁭􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁾􀀮􀁾_________________________________ Land Size 33.105 sguare feet Unit Price: As Improyed_____; Unimproved $4,08 Street Adjacent to airport taxi ways ___________ Utilities_____ improvments None at S.!!,l,"'e___________________________ Size and Description _____________________________ Condition and Desirability ___________________________ Current Use Unimproved Highest and Best Use Commercial -Hanl!er Date 􀁉􀁮􀁳􀁰􀁥􀁣􀁴􀁥􀁤􀁾􀁉􀀧􀁟􀀧􀁏􀀢􀁟􀁉􀁉􀀢􀀧􀀵􀀢􀁟􀀡􀀹􀀢􀀧􀀵􀀧􀁟_______ Zonin"'g_______________ Use reverse side for other pertinent information, _______________..,.-____ -• -:;? 'I ' Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority Form 200Ia Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT _..._------:-== Sales Parties: Grantor 􀁟􀁈􀀮􀀮􀀢􀀬􀁯􀀢􀀬􀁰􀁥􀀢􀀭􀀡􀀮􀀡􀁉􀁮􀀢􀀭􀀬􀁶􀀢􀀬􀁥􀁭􀀡􀁊􀁊􀁓􀀮􀁳􀁴􀀡􀁾􀁭􀀡􀀮􀀡􀀡� �􀀬􀀢􀁮􀀢􀀬􀁴􀁳􀁌􀀭_________ State Farm Mutual Grantee Automobile Invst. Co. Dated 1012/95 Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀧􀀭􀀲􀀹􀀺􀁤􀀮􀀵􀁾􀀱􀀹􀀺􀀺􀀮􀁊􀀱􀁌􀀭_____ Page 7045 Local Address NEC Addison Road & Airnort Parkway Legal Description Abstract 482, Addison, Texas Actual Price $600,000, Verified 􀁗􀁩􀁴􀁨􀀭􀀢􀁋􀀢􀀬􀁥􀀢􀀬􀁮􀁴􀀡􀁣􀀡􀁈􀁛􀀡􀀡􀁯􀁾􀁰􀀢􀀬􀁥􀀬􀀭􀀭____􀁾_____ Conditions of Sale-"C$,-,1.=.3.=.S.".0,.,0",0,,-. _________Verified Wilh George Roddv Conditions of Sale--'C"'a"'s"'h'--_____________________________ Rental Date __________________________________ Land Size 33.10S square feet Unit Price: As Improved______: Unimproved $4.08 Street Adjacent to airpon taxi wavs Utilities._____ Improvments None at Sale Size and Description _______________________________ Condition and Desirability _____________________________ Current Use Unimproved Highest and Best Use Commercial -Hanger Date Inspected,_-"10"'/....I""S/'-'9'-"S'--_______ Zoning,________________ Use reverse side for other pertinent information _____-:-______-.________ Q'LVk􀁾􀀱􀀱􀀠􀁾􀀠􀀠//&i{. Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority F onn 200 La Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT State Fann Mutual Grantee Alltomobile Invsl. Co.Sales Parties: Grantor ...wH"'o"'pc"'-llIn"'v"'em"-">stwm""ciJjn"'ts'- ________ Dated 10/2/95 ___ Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀮􀁾􀀹􀀢􀀬􀀵􀁃􀀡􀀮􀁬􀁌􀀹􀀬􀀬􀀢􀀬􀀱______ Page 7045 Local Address NEC Addison Road & Aimort Parl,-wav Legal Description Abstract 4.82. Addison. Texas Actual PriceJIi·"'OO"'.-"-OO"'O"'-.________Verified With'-"'K"e...􀁮􀁴􀀧􀀭􀀧􀁈􀁾􀁯􀁰􀀢􀀧􀁥􀀧􀁟􀁟__________ Conditions of Sale-'C"'a"'sh"-___________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁾􀀮� �__________________________________________ Land Size 2.4592.""A"'cr"'es"-___ Unit Price: As Improved__.. ___; Unimproved $5.60 Street Curb & Gutter 􀁕􀁴􀁩􀀱􀁩􀁴􀁩􀁥􀁳􀁾􀁁􀁬􀀬􀀢􀁌􀀬􀀭􀀭____ Improvments None at S"'a"'leL-______.________________________ Size and Description__-,-_____---___-----.______________ Seller will provide drainage expenditure estimated of$.25 per square foot Condition and Desirability for entire 15.8 􀁡􀁣􀁲􀁥􀁾􀀬􀀠􀀠of which this property was a part. Current Use U"'m,.p"'ro"'v"'ed"'-________ Highest and Best 􀁕􀁳􀁥􀁾􀁃􀀢􀀧􀁯􀁬􀀡􀀡􀁭􀁊􀀡􀁭􀀡􀀡􀀡􀁥􀀼� �􀀡􀁲􀀮􀁬􀁩􀀮􀁣􀁩􀀡􀁦􀀡􀁡􀀧􀁟􀁬_______ Date Inspected-".1"'2/"'2"'9"'/9"'5________ Zoning Commercial Appraiser FIELD NOTE DESCRIPTION SUB SURFACE AREA A PORTION OF ADDISON AIRPORT Wm. LOMAX SURVEY, ABSTRACf 792 E. COOK SURVEY, ABSTRACf 326 ADDISON, DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS EXHIBIT 3 Being 19S,683 square feet or 4.492 acres out ofa called 36S.34 acre tract as conveyed to the City ofAddison, by deed recorded in Volume 77010, Page 1391, Deed Records, Dallas County, Texas, said called 36S.34 acre tract being out of the Wm. Lomax Survey, Abstract 792 and the E. Cook Survey, Abstract 326, all in the City ofAddison, Dallas County, Texas and being more particular described as follows: (Bearings based on USC&GS Station "ARP 1966", with coordinates ofN 7,038,3SS.36-E 2,478,877.80 NAD83 and USC&GS Station "Airport Beacon", with coordinates ofN 􀀷􀀬􀀶􀁾􀀹􀀬􀀰􀀶􀀲􀀮􀀶􀀸􀀭􀁅 􀀠2,478,167.73 NAD83) BEGINNING, at a set S/8" iron rod on the Easterly line of Dooley Road (width varias), said iron rod being SS6°37'IS"E, a distance of 64.79 feet from the Northerly cut-back comer at the northeast comer of the intersection ofsaid Dooley Road with Keller Springs Road (SO feet wide); THENCE, NOOO43'S2"W, departing the Easterly line ofsaid Dooley Road, a distance of 18.61 feet to a point for coI'!ler; THENCE, N89°16'08"E, a distance of 174.25 feetto a point for comer at the beginning ofa tangent curve to the right, said curve having a radius of 1763.00 feet; THENCE, continuing along said curve to the right, having a central angle of 05°47'20", a chord bearing of S87°50'12"E, a chord distance ofl78. 05 feet, and an arc distance ofl78.13 feet to a point oftangency; THENCE, S84°56'32"E, a distance of 1,301.25 feet to a point for comer; THENCE, S05°03'28"W, a distance of 126.00 feet to a point for comer; THENCE, N84°56'32" W, a distance of 1,301.25 feet to a point for comer at the beginning of a tangent curve to the left having a radius of 1,637.00 fcet; THENCE, continuing along said curve to the left, having a central angie of 05°47'20", a chord bearing of N87°50'12"W, a chord distance of 165.33 feet, and an arc distance of 165.40 feet to the point oftangeney; THENCE, S89°16'08"W, a distance of48.34 feet to a point for comer on.the Easterly line ofDooley Road; THENCE, NOoo12'22"W, continuing along said Easterly line 92.32 feet to a comer on the Northerly line of Dooley Road; THENCE, S 89°42'54"W, continuing along said Northerly line ofDooley Road, a distance of 105.72 feet to a point for comer; TImNCE, N56°37'15"W, continuing along the Northerly line ofDooley Road, a distance of25.41 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING, and containing 195,683 square feet or 4.492 acres in the metes and bounds recited. This is to certifY that the above description was prepared from an on the ground survey conducted under my suparvision. 􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀺􀁾􀀱􀁲􀁦􀁦􀂱􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀻􀀨􀁾􀀮􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀧􀁾􀀮􀁑􀀺􀀺􀀺� �􀀺􀁏􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀺􀁾􀁟􀀠DATE: 􀀯􀁊􀁚􀀮􀀯􀁾􀀿􀁉'1;􀀺􀀧􀀬􀁾􀀠􀀯􀁜􀁹􀁴􀀡􀁾􀀺􀀺􀀠R. S}\NDHU l:j eAuthority Ja. '1 􀁦􀀹􀁱􀁾􀀠􀁜􀀧􀀬􀀼􀁜􀀢􀁾􀀧􀀾􀂷􀀩􀀻􀁾􀀧􀁩􀀻􀁻􀀧􀀧􀀧􀁾􀀧􀀧􀀱'\2{' 􀀮􀀺􀁾􀀬􀀮􀀨􀀩􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀢􀀢.. 􀀢􀀧􀂷􀁯􀁾􀁾􀂷􀁯􀀼􀁣􀁦􀀢􀀠􀀺􀀬􀁲􀀮􀀺􀂷􀀯􀀢􀀮􀁉􀀧􀁲􀀺􀁾􀁴􀀻􀀻􀀺􀁜􀀠.'1. ...:y:." 􀀻􀀢􀀢􀁾􀀺􀀢􀀧􀁴􀁾􀀻􀀺􀀺􀀧􀁾􀂷􀁴􀀨􀀻􀀮􀁾􀀠;:... 􀀢􀀺􀀧􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀺􀁾􀀮􀁣􀀺􀀺􀀺􀁾􀀠S· u}1"!..? 􀀭􀀮􀀮􀀮􀁾􀀮􀁆􀀺􀀻􀀺􀀡􀁩􀀺􀁦� �􀀺􀀧􀀻􀀮􀀠 Texas Turnpike Authority Fonn 2001a ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number ___--:______ Address Hanger 1000, 4739 Keller Springs Add res s _____________Owner City ofAddison Occupant's Name Allen Tillev Whole 􀀢􀁲􀀺􀀮􀀮􀀧􀁾􀀮􀀺.•;:.'.o;.____ Partial Taking X Purpose ofthe Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible tc highway use of the subject property as of 12/20/95. It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein will be used for settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered fur sale by one who desires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probabiljty will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation In my opinion the compensation due as a result ofthis taking is: Owner $ _______ Leasehold Interest $_______ Total $324.758. Appraiser's Certificate I hereby certify that the opInIon of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notify the Authority of such interest or interests. waJ/UiAppraiser Approved by the Board of Directors 􀁒􀁩􀁧􀁨􀁴􀀭􀁯􀁦􀀭􀁗􀁡􀁾􀀠Co Fonn 20013 Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No,_______ Local Address,__􀀭􀀢􀁈􀁁􀀽􀁎􀁇􀀢􀀬􀁅􀀢􀀬􀁒􀀢􀀭􀀬􀁬􀀭􀀬􀀬􀁏􀀢􀀬􀁏􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁏􀀭􀀬􀁋􀁾􀁅􀀺􀀺􀀺􀁌􀁾􀁌􀀺􀀽􀀺􀁅􀁾􀁒􀀭􀀬􀁓􀀺􀀺􀀮􀀺􀁐􀁣􀀮􀀺􀁒􀀺� �􀀺􀀺􀁉􀁾􀁎􀁇􀁯􀁣􀁓􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀭􀀭____ Date Taken.-.JUl19j AND 11110/95 Taken by CHARLES (80) HILLER 1. Point from which taken ___􀀭􀀢􀁋􀀺􀀮􀀺􀀺􀁅􀀺􀀮􀀺􀀺􀁌􀀺􀀮􀀺􀀺􀁌􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀺􀁅􀀡􀀺􀀮􀁒􀁾􀁓􀁐􀁾􀁒􀀽􀁉􀁎􀀺􀀺 􀀺􀁇􀀺􀀺􀀮􀀺􀁓􀁾􀀠__􀁾..􀁟􀁾􀁾Looking 􀁟􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀺􀁎􀀺􀀧􀁏􀀺􀁒􀀺􀁔􀀺􀁈􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀻􀁾􀁟1---' _. 2. Point from which taken ____􀀭􀀽􀀭􀁔􀀧􀀭􀀧􀁁􀁘􀁾􀁉􀁩􀀡􀁃􀀺􀀻􀁁􀀢􀀭􀁙􀀽􀀭________ Looking__-"S"'OU"-'T"'H"- ___ Fonn 200Ia Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description Abstract 792, A"""dd"'i"'so"'n!"JM"""u!'-m""c""ip"'a1'-'A"""irp""o"'rt"'-______________ Dimensions: 144,17 feet x _3".,5""0'--____feet -50,462 sq,ft. ______ Acres Location (Urban): Street & No, _________-;-____on side between -;:;:---;:-_____________ and ____________streets, (Rural): ____----:_-:-=_-:::-_______________ :-::-:-:-:--:-----:-_;-'---:---:--:---::==-Land Grant Survey ___;-:---::-:--;--:--;-_-;--:-_____ Neighborhood or Area Analysis: The Neighborhood is a commercial and industrial area, having restaurant, neighborhood service, office, office showroom and warehouse facilities, A major asset in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation, The subject is located on Airport property. Highest and Best Use and Zoning of Subject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial -3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: 18,761 ft. @$23.00 per square focL""""",$431.503. Parking Lot: $ 1 .15 per square ft ,,31,701 sq,ft.".""""",$ 36.456. Total Reproduction"" """""...... , .. , ", ..." ..... " ... ""..... ,.,...,.." ............. , .. " ................ $467.959. Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration" .... " .......... ,' ..." .40% ...... " ... ",,,,, .."""""".. ",,, $187,184. Functional Obsolescence """"..""....... "".", """..""" ....... " .... " .." ...... $ -0Economie Obsolesscence .................. " ......... ".".""................... " ........ $ -0Total Depreciation ""...."".. ,, .......""""".""..........................""...... " ............... " ..... $187, 184. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property ................... ", ............................... ""........."".... $280,775. Garages: ft. @$ per ft""....""............"""..""""...............$___ Less Depreciation .......................... " ..................... " ..................... " ....................... $ $,___ Other (Detail) ............................................ " ......... , .... """.................""""....... "".. ".$__ Less Depreciation .."""""..... , ............ ""...... " ........... , ..",,..., ................ " ... " .. "..".,$ $,___ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $ __,.....,., Fencing $,____, Walks $ , Drives $ .... " ...""........................... " ........... ", .." ..................$___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property ., ...... , .." ............ , .... ", .......................... "'$___ LAND ... " ........ 50,462 square feet "'$3"',"'00"--__per,sq.ft ................................................ ,.$151,386. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH .............................................. ",,,, ................... $432.l61. Comment on Depreeiation Factors: Fonn 2001a Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPER1Y (Land Comparables) Purchase Price of Subject Property $---------------Date'--________ Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Infonnation of Comparable Properties SALE NO. 3 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10/31/94 Hope Invt. Ltd. Addison, Ltd. 3121195 M&F Development Co Diversco Mann 04117/95 Chaiu Chin AER SALE CONFIRMED WTIH ADDRESS & LOCATION IN RELATION TO SUBJECT Kent Hope 4901 Airport Pkwy, 344.47' E Addison Rd -'1..."B""lk...S"'o"'u""th>--___ George Roddy 4500 bJk Sunbelt, Approx. 667' W. of Addison Rd 5 blks N. Pat Hag:g:ert;y 2030 Chenault @Earhart southeast corner ACTUAL SALE PRlCE $742,000. $125.000. $530.500. CONDmONS OF SALE Cash Cash Cash ESTIMATED UNIT PRlCE ..I3.10 $2.76 $3.00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA CURRENT USAGE Federal Express Distribution Facilitv UnimprOVed Warehouse under Constnlction IDGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Commercial Commercial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale None at sale None at sale Correlation of Comparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $ 151,386. Fonn 200la Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION: Subject is under a ground lease with original 40 yr tenn. The lease has approximately 23 yrs and 8 mo. remaining. Net income from building is capitalized at 12%. 10.5% is the rate established as fair return on the land. Estimated remaining economic life of improvements,....2"'5c.;v.." ea""r!.jls'--______________ Stabilized Gross Income............................................ $ 58.320. Vacancy 15 %............................................ 8.748. Effective Gross Income..................................................................................................... , ..... $49.572. Taxes: City .............................................................. .......... $ ___ State & County ....................................................... $ ___ Miscellaneous (School, etc.}....................................$___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage......................................$_-",2",-24"-" Miscellaneous ......................................................... $----c,.,-,. Annual Deferred Maintenance ......................... ........... $ 600. Management 4 % ...................................... $ 1.983. Operating Expenses ..Utilities..................................... $ 1.400. Other Expenses ......................... ...... $ ___ Total El'penses before Depreciation ........................................................................................ $ 4,207. Net Income to Property ............................. .............................................................................. $ 45.365. Less Income Attributable to (Land} ............................ $ @% .................... $ 15,896. Income Attributable to (Improvements) .................................................................................. $ 29,469. Income Capitalized@,.."1",,2__% (1--__% Interest ___% for Recapture of Capital) ..... $245.575. (Land) (Improvements) ........................................................................................................... $151,386. Present value of $ I ,458/mo. or $17,496/yr + present value ofland revises value. ESTIMA TED VALUE BY CAPITALIZAnON APPROACH .............................................. $396,96 I. (Say) $397,000. ADDITIONAL APPRAISAL INFORMATION FOnTI 2001a Page 6 FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE OFVVHOLEPROPERTY Correlaton of Approaches to Value See Page 6A Estimated Value of Whole Property Owner $ Leasehold $,_____ .......•••....•.•.••.•.. ' ..............................$____ ,.-.-. 6A CORRELATION The City ofAddison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement tenninates on December 31, 2000. Several ground leases extend beyond that date. This property is under a ground lease with an original term of forty years, as of November 1, 1995. Twenty three (23) years, eight (8) months remain on the lease. For purposes ofthis report, it is assumed that the property is owned and operated by the fee owner. The fair market value estimated herein does not attempt to determine the value ofthe leased fee, the sublease position (sandwich position) ofthe airport management or the leasehold estate created by the lease for the tenant currently in possession ofthe property. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value ofthe subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units ofcomparison derived from sales ofsimilar properties in the marketplace. Those units ofcomparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative ofthe market estimate ofvalue for the subject property. The Income Approach to· Value is based upon an analysis ofthe income stream ofthe property and comparison ofthat income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate ofvalue . . The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal of substitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value ofthe site, the reproduction cost ofthe improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue, The market approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land. Sale #1 is located one hlock south ofthe subject and east of Addison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north ofthe subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west ofthe subject and on the west side of Addison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property . . These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity of Addison Airport used for commercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of$3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market . value ofthe land before the taking taking for the land taken, and for the land value after the taking. At $3,00 per square foot the fair market value ofthe land is $151,386. When $3,00 is multiplied times 23,407 square feet, fair market value ofthe land taken for the right ofway equals $70,221. A temporary construction easement of 11,600 square feet is also being taken. Just compensation for the land taken under the construction easement equals $7,308. 100% ofthe building is being taken with a value of $245,575. attributed to the improvements. The income approach is the most reliable indicator ofvalue ofthe subject. The cost approach indicates an upper limit ofvalue when the improvements are new and constitute the highest and best use for the property, :-..; The income stream generated bv the property can be compared to income from other investments available in the market with similar and .ied degrees ofrisk and durability. Direct capitalization -building residual tecimique is used to estimate the value ofthe property under the income approach. The land value has been established at $154,386. from comparable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate retum on the value ofthe land or $15,896. When this income is subtracted from net income to property, $29,469. of income is attributed to the improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to the improvements of $245,575. The sums ofthe value ofland and value ofthe improvements equals the estimated value ofthe whole property of$396,961 (say $397,000.). The income approach is the most accurate estimate ofthe fair market value. Therefore $397,000. is the fair market value ofthe subject before the taking. The value of the remainder before the taking is $81,165. ($396,961 less $315,796). After the taking, the improvements are removed. 27,055 square feet ofland remains with a value equal to $81,165. The value ofthe remainder after the taking is unchanged and is equal to $81,165. In addition to taking ofthe improvement and the surface easement, a temporary construction easement will be taken. It is estimated that this easement will be needed for a period of two years and that compensation wll be equal to 10.5% ofthe fair market value ofthe land for that period (11,600 sq.ft. + 2,625 sq.ft.= 14,225 sq.ft. x $3 x 10.5% x 2 yrs. = $8,961.75. Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $245,575. Right of Way Taken 70,221. $315,796. Construction Easement 8,962. Taken Total Just Compensation $324,758. 􀁾􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀠-' :. -:. ':. Fonn 200la Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKING Legal Description Part Taken ________________________ '. Dimensions x 341 =50.127 Sq.Ft. Acres WHOLE PROPERTY:. The market value ofthe whole property is ................. $ 396.961. PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oi!, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is: ........................................................................................ $315,796 (I) REMAINING PROPERTY: The market value ofthe remiander inunediately before the taking is: .............................................................. $ 81,165. (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder immediately after the taking is: ................................... $ 81,165. (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany.................................................................................. ..................$_""-0""-__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, ifany ............... " ......... " ................................................... $,::-:-::,::-0,;;;.--,--_ TOTAL COMPENSATION ..................................... ,."., ....................... " ........... $315,796. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of Part Taken ::--:::--=cc:-------------------R emainder Before Taking --:-c;--:--:;----:--:--:-:--;--------:---Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected ______ Contributory Value of Improvements Part Taken Remainder Before Taking Remainder After Taking Bldg.-18,761 sf(100%) $245,575. TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS RIGHT OF WAY 23,407 sf@$3. 70,221. $ 81,165. $ 81.165. TOTAL AS A UNIT . $315,796, (1) 81,165. (2) 81,165. (3) CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + 8,962. • $324,758. Explain difference, ifany, between Remainder Before and After Taking (1f extra space needed, use attachment.) Form 200 la Page & #1 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT 􀀮􀀭􀀭􀁾􀀮􀀭􀀮􀀭􀀭􀀢􀀢􀀧􀀠·'-r.-?·",itt----·---'" , .•.... ; .. I , ..-----------"=--..􀁾􀁾􀀠-Sales Parties: Grantor Hope 􀁉􀁮􀁣􀁹􀀺􀁶􀁥􀁳􀁳􀁴􀀢 􀀬􀁭􀀢􀀬􀁥􀀲􀀡􀁮􀁾􀁴􀁊􀀬􀁌􀀢􀀢􀁴􀁤􀀢􀀬􀀮􀁾_____ Grantee Addison Ltd. Dated_-,1",0",,/31/94 ___Recorded in Volume-"9"'4"'2...IO"-______ Page 3570 Local Address 490 I Airport Parkway Legal Description Abst. 482. Tract 30. Addison. TX ____􀁖􀁥􀁲􀁩􀁦􀁩􀁥􀁤􀁜􀁖􀁩􀁩􀁬􀁩􀀭􀁌􀁋􀁾􀁥􀁾􀁮􀁾􀁴􀁈􀁾􀁯􀁷􀁰􀁥􀁌􀁟_____________Actual Price $742.000. Conditions of Sale-'C""a"'shLL______________________ _________ Rental Date________________________________ Land Size 5.4963 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____; Unimproved..,$""3"'.lo.oO'--___ Street 􀁾􀁃􀀢􀀢􀁬􀁬􀁬􀁩􀁬􀁲􀁾􀁢􀀧􀀭􀀧􀀦􀁾􀁇􀁵􀁾􀁴􀁴􀁥􀀡􀂣􀁌� �________________ Utilities_______ Impro\ments None at sale Size and Description __-::--c:-_-,-____----:--,-_-:-_-:---c __-,-________----Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance of the tract ofwhich Condition and Desirability this is a part. Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best Use_-"C"'ollmm!ll'Sc""rc""ia"'I'--________ Date Inspected 7!I5/95 ________ Zoning Commercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent information ___-=__-------,,,----􀁦􀀡􀁊􀀮􀁴􀁚􀀨􀁩􀀡􀁦􀀻􀀨􀁾􀀠Appraiser Fonn 200la Page 8 #2 􀁾􀁾􀁾_______􀀮􀁟􀁾􀁶􀀧􀁎􀁬􀁲􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀱􀁟􀁾􀁓􀁁􀁌􀁅􀁓􀁄􀁁􀁔􀁁􀁾􀁕􀁐􀀱􀀧􀁌􀁅􀁉􀁾􀁅􀁬􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀠 Sales Parties: Grantor M&: F Development Co.. Inc. Grantee Manufacturing Dated 3/21195 Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀬􀁾􀀹􀀢􀀬􀀵􀀰􀁦􀀮􀀰􀁾􀀢􀀬􀀭)"--______Page ""4"'6"'3'--__ Local Address 4500 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description West Y, _Tract 13 Sunbelt Business Park Addition. Addison. TX Actual Price $125.000, Verified With George Roddy ___________ Conditions of 􀁓􀁡􀁬􀁥􀀭􀀬􀁃􀀢􀀬􀁡􀀢􀀬􀁳􀀢􀀬􀁨􀁾___________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁾􀀬􀀬______________________ _________________________ Land Size 1.0382 Acres Unit Price: As Improved ______; Unimproved $2.76 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter 􀁕􀁴􀁩􀀡􀁩􀁴􀁩􀁥􀁳􀀬􀁾􀁁􀀢􀀬􀁉􀀡􀀡􀀮􀁉___ Improvments None at Sale Size and Description LeveL ready for development Condition and Desirability _________________________________________________ : . Current Use,__-"U"'n"'im=pr"'o'-'v"'ed"-________ Highest and Best Use Light Industrial & Corrunercial Date Inspected 71151955 ... ___________ Zoning Commercial -1 Use reverse side for other pertinent infonnation _____-,,-______-,.______________--;- +____ Ie" IJ hJ/Y/)" //' __-,L/;",-",,2j_{..._'....:c:..:..'&:::':.../;;r/􀀣􀁴􀁾􀀠Appraiser Form 200 I a Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEYIEN I -----􀀭􀁾􀀭􀀧􀀭􀀧􀀭􀀭􀁾􀀽􀀠Sales Parties: Grantor _C"'h"'a"'i,..u..,C"'h"'in"-__________ Grantee 􀁾􀁁􀁅􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀬􀀽􀀭􀀬􀀭􀀬􀁒􀁾______ Dated 4/14,"'/9""5'---________ Recorded in Volume,---Z.9"'50"-'7C!4______ Page -,6",6",8__ Local Address 2030 Chenault. Carrollton, TX Legal Description Abstract 923, Tract 20 Actual Price $530."'50"'0"",_______ Verified With Pat HaQQeti': Conditions of Sale-"C"'a.,.sh"--___________________________ RenrnIDma________________________________ Land Size 40592 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____; Unimproved $3,00 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter Utilities,-o.A....I...1 _____ Improvrnents None at Sale Size and Description,______________________________ Condition and Desirability___________________________ Current Use...J.Yarehollse under constru<;,,,,,ito,,,n,--_ Highest and Best )Jse-"C",o",mrn"",e",rc",i""a,-l_____􀁾􀀠Date Inspected 10/22/95 ",__",____ Zoning Commercia!-! Use reverse side for other pertinent inforrnation ________--:-________,---__ ? /" //J/' 1;/b 'i/,,<-,.4 /,7t 􀀡􀀯􀁦􀁦􀁾􀀯􀁕􀁬􀀠Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority Fonn 200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number _________􀁾􀀠Address Hanger 1100 Keller Springs Owner City ofAddison Address_____________ Occupant's na.."·_________ Whole Taking ____ Partial Taking X Purpose ofthe Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subject property as of 12/20/95. It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein will be used for settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered for sale by one who desires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation Tn my opinion the compensation due as a result ofthis taking is: Owner $152,350. Leasehold Interest $,______ Total $152.350, Appraiser's Certificate I hereby certifY that the opinion of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notifY the Authority of such interest or interests. Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-Way Form 2001a Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel,w,_, ___________ Local Address__---=HA=N.::G=.ER"---'I'-'I"'O-"O_K:.:.E"'L"'L""E:.:;R'-"-SP"'R"'I"'N"'G"'S____ DateTaken 9/7/95 AND 11/10/95 Taken by CHARLES ,(BO) MILLER I, Point from which taken ___ KELLER SPRINGS ____ LOOking,,==N::OR::T::H=::;;;;;;;;-_ 2_Porntfromwhlchbken___􀁾􀁔􀁾􀁁􀁘􀁾􀁉􀁾􀁗􀁁􀁾􀁙􀁾_________ 􀁌􀁯􀁯􀁫􀁦􀁦􀁩􀀮􀁾􀁧__􀁾􀁓􀁏􀁾􀁕􀁾􀁔􀁾􀁈􀁾____ Form 200 Ia Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description Abstract 792, Addision Municipal Airport Dimensions: 127.5 feet x 􀁾􀀳􀀢􀀬􀀴􀀢􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀭􀀭____feet -43,350 sq.ft. ,995 Acres Location (Urban): Street & No. _________-:-____on.________side between -:=::---:::-_____________and ____________streets. (Rural): __________________________ 􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁌􀁡􀁮􀁤􀁇􀁲􀁡􀁮􀁴􀁓 􀁵􀁾􀁥􀁹􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀂭Neighborhood or Area Analysis: The Neighborhood is a commercial and industriaJ area, having restaurant, neighborhood service, office, office showroom and warehouse facilities. A major assct in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation. The subject is located on Airport property. Highest and Best Use and Zoning of Subject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial -3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: 15.300 ft, @$23,00 per square foot .., .......... $351,900. Parking Lot: $1.1 5 per sguare ft ..28,050 sq,ft ............. ,,$ 32,258. Total Total Reproduction .................. " ... "".....""",..................................................... .... $384,158, Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration .......................... 40% ....................................... $153,663, Functional Obsolescence .... ', .............. , ............. , ....... , .." ............... ", , ..$ -0Economic Obsolesscence ................. "".,... , ................. , .. , ................ , ... $ -0Total Depreciation ......... " .......................................... , ................ ," .............. , .......... $153,663. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property .......... , .................................... .................... " ..... $230,495. Garages: ft. @$ per ft.... " .......... " ................... " ........... " ... $___ Less Depreciation ................................. " ................ ,., ............................... , ........... $ $,____ . Other (Detail) ........................................................ "" ....... , ......... , ........................ " ... $ ___ Less Depreciation ........................................ , ......... , .......... , ........... """..... " ........... $ $'--__ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $ __::::-::,,' Fencing $ ___􀁾􀀠Walks $ • Drives $ .................................. , .................... " ..................... $ ___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property ........................... ................................ $230,495. LAND ..... " ..... ,43,350 square feet ""$3"".0""0'---__per.sq.ft .. , ............................................... $130,050. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH ....................................................................... $360.545. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Form 200 I a Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTI (Land Comparables) Date_________Purchase Price of Subject Property $_-----Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information of Comparable Properties SALE NO. 3 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10/31/94 Hope Invt. Ltd. Addison, Ltd. 3121/95 M&F Development Co Diversco Mann 04/17/95 Chaiu Chin AER SALE CONFIRMED WITH ADDRESS & LOCATION IN RELATION TO SUBJECT Kent HO)2e 4901 Airport Pkwy, 344.47' E Addison Rd I Blk South Qeorge Roddy 4500 blk Sunbelt, Approx. 667' W. of Addison Rd 5 blks N. Pat H aggertv 2030 Chenault @Earhart southeast comer ACTUAL SALE PRICE $742.000, $125,000. $530.500, CONDITIONS OF SALE Cash Cash Cash ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE $3,10 $2,76 $3.00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA CURRENT USAGE Federal Express Distribution Facilitv Unimproved Warehouse under Constmction HIGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Commercial Commercial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale None at sale None at sale Correlation of Comparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $-"1",30"""0,,.,5,,,0,,-.___ Fonn 200la Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPER1Y mSTIFICA TION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION: Direct capitalization is used to estimate the value of subiect. 10.5% is the rate established as fair rate of return value on the land and 12% is selected as fair return on the improvements. Estimated remaining economic life of improvements...,2""5CJvClVHOLEPROPERTY Correlaton ofApproaches to Value See Page 6A Estimated Value of Whole Property Owner $ Leasehold .. _____ ................................... ....................$____ ) . 6A CORRELATION The City ofAddison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement terminates on December 31, 2000. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value ofthe subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units of comparison derived from sales of similar properties in the marketplace. Those units of comparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative ofthe market estimate of value for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis of the income stream of the property and comparison of that income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate of value. The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal of substitution for a properiy should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value ofthe site, the reproduction cost ofthe improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue. The market approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land. Sale # 1 is located one block south ofthe subject and east of Addison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north of the subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west of the subject and on the west side of Addison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property. These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity of Addison Airport used for commercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of$3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market value ofthe land before the taking for the land taken, and for the land value after the taking. At $3.00 per square foot the fair market value of the land is $130,050. When $3.00 is multiplied times 17,887 square feet, fair market value of the land taken for the right of way equals $53,661. A temporary two year construction easement of 2,37 5 square feet is also being taken. Just compensation for the land taken under the construction easement equals $1,496. 9,247 square feet or 60.55'Yoofthe building is being taken with a value of$96,059. attributed to this part ofthe improvements. ($158,933. improvement value x 60.44%). The income approach is the most reliable indicator of value ofthe subject. The cost approach indicates an upper limit ofvalue when the improvements are new and constitute the highest and best use for the property. The income stream generated by the property can be compared to income from other investments avai lable in the market with similar and varied degrees of risk and durability. 􀀨􀀮􀀺􀁾􀀠i·".. Direct capitalization -building 􀁔􀁾􀁳􀁩􀁤􀁵􀁡􀁬􀀠technique is used to estimate tbe val.•" oftbe property under tbe income approach. The land v<. ;has been established at $130,050. from l .parable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate return on tbe value oftbe land or $13,655. When this income is subtracted from net income to property, $ I 9,On. of income is attributed to tbe improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to tbe improvements 0[$ 158,933. The sums oftbe value ofland and value oftbe improvements equals tbe estimated value oftbe whole property of$288,983. The income approach is tbe most accurate estimate oftbe fair market value. Therefore $288,983. is tbe fair market value oftbe subject before tbe taking. The value oftbe remainder before tbe taking is $139,263. ($288,983 less$149,nO). After tbe taking, tbe improvements are reduced by 9,247 square feet or 60.44% oftbe value oftbe improvements leaving approximately 6,053 square feet. The remaining improvements will generate income on a prorata business equivalent to income generated before tbe taking. Therefore, tbe value oftbe remainder after tbe taking is unchanged and is equal to $139,263. In addition to taking a portion oftbe improvement and tbe right ofway, a temporary construction easement will be taken. This easement will be needed for a period oftwo years and tbat compensation wll be equal to 10.5% oftbe fair market value oftbe land for tbat period (2,375 sq.ft. + 1,800 sq.ft. = 4,175 sq.ft. x $3. x 10.5% x 2 yrs. = $2,630.25). Totaljust compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $96,059. Right ofWay Taken 53,661. $149,720. Construction Easement 2,630. Taken Total Just Compensation $152,350. Fonn 2001a Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKING Legal Description Part Taken ________________________ Dimensions x = Sq.Ft. Acres WHOLE PROPERlY: The market value ofthe whole property is ................. $ 288.983. PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is: ............................ ............................................................ $149.720. (1) REMAINING PROPERlY: The market value of the remiander immediately before the taking is: .................................... .......................... $ 139.263. (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder immediately after the taking is: ........................ ........... $ 139,263. (3) NET DAMAGES, if any ................................................................................................... $_..;:-0""-__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, if any ............................................................................... $.:-::;,.::-O"::'-':-_ TOTAL COMPENSATION ...................................................................... ......... $149,720. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAJNDER Highest and Best Use of Part 􀁔􀁡􀁫􀁥􀁮􀁾􀀻􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀻􀀺􀀻􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭____________________ Remainder Before Taking --:c:c-:--;-----:-:-:--::- ---------Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected ____________________ Contributory Value of Improvements Part Taken Remainder Before Taking Remainder After Taking Bldg.-9,247 sf(60.44%) 96,059. 62.874. 62,874. TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS RIGIIT OF WAY LAND 17,887 S.F. @$3. 53,661. 76,389. 76.389. TOTAL AS A UNIT $149,720. (1) $139,263. (2) $139,263. (3) CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + 2,630. $152,350. Explain difference, ifany, between Remainder Befure and After Taking (Ifextra space needed, use attachment.) Fonn 200 la Page 8 Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd, Grantee Addison Ltd, Dated,_--"1"'01!...i3"'1L;19,,4'--__ _____ Recorded in Vo]ume-i9"'4""2.!C1O"-_____ Page 3570 Local Addrcss 4901 Airport Parkwav Legal Description Abst. 482. Tract 30. Addison, TX Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀼􀁌􀀷􀀲􀀴􀀷􀀢􀀢􀁟􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀮􀁾_______Vcrified With-"K",c",n"-.t􀁈􀀢􀀭􀀢􀀢􀀬􀁯� �􀀲􀀢􀀬􀀬􀁥􀁾__________ Conditions ofSale-'C"'a"'s"'h______________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁾􀀬______.__________ ,_________________ Land Size 5 􀀮􀀴􀀹􀀶􀀳􀂷􀀭􀀧􀁁􀁾􀁣􀀢􀀧􀁲􀀢􀀢􀀧􀁥􀁳􀀢􀁟____ Unit Price: As Improved,___ ; 􀁕􀁮􀁩􀁭􀁰􀁲􀁯􀁶􀁥􀁤􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀳􀁾􀀬1...,0'---__ Strect__-'C"u"'r"'b""&"-"G"'u"'tl"'er'--_______________ Utilities__________ Improvrnents None at sale Size and Description__-c----c-___----c----c---::-----,----_c---c--:----Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance of the tract of which Condition and Desirability_t",h",is,-!i",s",a-l>p",a",rt"",__ ________________________ Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best Use,_-,C",o",mrn"""e",·r",ci",a,-I__􀁾_____ Date Inspected'---'-7!..11"'5<.v"'e"'d'-_________ Highest and Best Use Light Industrial & Commercial Date 􀁉􀁮􀁳􀁰􀁥􀁣􀁴􀁥􀁤􀁟􀀷􀀧􀀭􀀧􀀯􀁾􀀱􀀢􀀢􀀧􀀵􀀱􀀢􀀧􀀹􀀢 􀀧􀀵􀀭􀀢􀀵________ Zoning Commercial -I Use reverse side for other pertinent information ______________________ . ?:f:!/P'!C£􀁾􀀠. Appraiser Form 200 la Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA 􀁓􀁕􀁐􀁐􀁌􀁅􀁍􀁅􀀮􀁾􀀽􀁎􀀺􀀮􀀺􀁔􀁾􀀬.._, _______"""""-,,, Sales Parties: Grantor -"'C:.!.!ha"i"'uwC"'h:.!.!i"'n___________ Grantee 􀀭􀁄􀀢􀀢􀀧􀁾______ Dated 4114/95 Recorded in Vo!ume,---'9"'5"'O.!..:74"-_______ Page _6",6",8,-__ Local Address 2030 Chenault. Carrollton. TX Legal Description Abstract 923. Tra"'c"'-t""2"'0______________________ Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀢􀀢􀀵􀁤􀀳􀀰􀀩􀁌􀀮􀀢􀀢􀀵􀀢􀀧􀀰􀀢􀀧􀀰􀀮􀁾________Verified With Pat Hrurgertv Conditions of Sale,--'C"'a"'s"'h____________________________ Rental Data,_________________________ _______ Land Size 4.0592 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____•Unimproved $3.00 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter _____________ Uti!ities---,-A",ILI----Improvrnents None at Sale Size and Description________ _____________________ Condition and Desirability___________________________ Current Use Warehouse under constmciton Highest and Best Use,--,C""o"m",m:.!.!e",r",c",ial!..!_______ Date Inspected---"'1"'0"'12"'2""'19""S'---_______ Zoning Commercial-! Use reverse side for other pertinent infonnation, ________________-;;---;-__ /:lc:c£ 4: /;)j/k.!L; L/' Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority Form 200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL EST A TE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number __________ Address Hanger 1200 Keller Sprin2S Address_____________Owner City ofAddison Occupant's Narne,_________ Whole Taking ____ Partial Taking X Purpose ofthe Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subject property as of 12/20/95, It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein will be used for settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered for sale by by one who desires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation In my opinion the compensation due as a result of this taking is: Owner 􀀤􀀢􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀳􀀹􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀬􀁾􀀵􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀳􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀭􀀮_____ Leasehold Interest $,______ Total $ 39.503. Appraiser's Certificate I hereby certify that the opInion of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notify the Authority of such interest or interests. (lLdJdiitlAppraiser : ., Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-Wa Fonn 200la Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No. Local Address. HANGER 1200 KELLER SPRINGS Date Taken 9/7/95 AND .11 II 0/95 Taken by __􀀭􀀢􀁃􀀢􀀬􀁈􀀢􀀬􀁁􀁒􀀢􀀬􀁌􀁥􀀬􀁅􀀢􀀬􀁓􀀬􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀬􀀨􀁾� �􀁏􀀢􀀭􀀩􀁌􀀭􀀭􀀧􀀮􀁍􀀽􀀽􀁉􀀢􀀬􀁌􀀢􀀬􀁌􀀢􀀢􀁅􀁒􀀬􀀬􀀭_____ I. Point from which taken __--'K"'E""L"'L"'E"'R'--"S-"-P"'R-=I"NG""S"---_ _..____ Looking _...IN'''O''''RL!T.1JH'--___ 2. Point from which taken ___--'T""AX"'""I"'W"'A"'-Y__________ Looking_--'S"'O-=U.=T"'H____ Fonn 200 I a Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description Abstract 792, Addison Municipal Airport Dimensions: 127 fectx 􀁾􀀳􀀴􀀢􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀭􀀭____ feet-43,180 sq,ft, ,9913 Acres Location (Urban): Street & No, _________-:-____on________side between -,---c7'"-------------and ____________streets, (Rural): _____􀁾􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀺􀀺􀀭􀁟􀀽􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀂭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁌� �􀁮􀁤􀁇􀁲􀁡􀁮􀁴􀁓􀁵􀁾􀁥􀁹􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀂭Neighborhood or Area Analysis: The Neighborhood is a commercial and industrial area, having restaurant, neighborhood 􀁳􀁥􀁾􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀬􀀠office, office showroom and warehouse facilities, A major asset in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation, The subject is located on Airport property, Highest and Best Use and Zoning of Subject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial-3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: 16,640 ft. @$15,00 per square foot"", .. ", .. ,$249,600. Parking Let: $1.15 . per square ft ..26,540 sq,ft ... " .......... $ 30,52 L Total Reproduction ...... " ..... " " ........ " ....... ",,, .. ,,.,, ............ " ..... "".. " ..... """"""...... $280.121. Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration ... ".."".... " .. ",,, . .40% ..... ",...... " ....... ", ..... ",,, ... $112.048. Functional Obsolescence .." ... " ...... " ... " ..... " ... ""."..............""""""".$ -0Economic Obsolesscence """....... " ......... " ..... " ....... ""................ " ...... $ -0Total Depreciation .. ""....","'..... " ........................................ " .. ""..... " ... ""............ ,,$112.048. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property .. "'.. " ........ ",.. ", ........ , .. "'",,,.......... ,,,, .. , ............ .$168.073, Garages: ft, @$ per ft." .... " ................... " ........... " ......".".$___ Less Depreciation ......... ""... " .... " ....... "" ............."."..............."""........ , .... , ..... ",,$ $___ Other (Detail)" .. , ... " .... " .. "" .................... " .... ", ... " ...........".'........ ' .................. ",. " .... $__ Less Depreciation .,..................... " .............. " .. '", ................ "".,... " ........... " ...... ,""$ $___ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $__-:::::-:-" Fencing $ ___􀁾􀀠Walks $ , Drives $ ......... ", ........................ ",.....""..... " .. "."".............. $ ___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property .... ",,, ........... ,,,,"',, .............. ,,,, ...... ,,,,,, ..$168,073. LAND".." ...... ,43,180 square feet $"'3"".0"'0"-__per.sq.ft ........................ " ..... ""............. $129,540. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH .................... ""'.""... "",,,,,,,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ........$297,613. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Form 200 I a Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY (Land Comparables) $_------Date,_________Purchase Price of Subject Property Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information ofComparable Properties SALE NO. 1 2 3 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10/31194 Hope Invt Ltd. Addison, Ltd. 3121/95 M&F Development Co Diversco Mann 04117/95 Chaiu Chin AER SALE CONFIRMED WTIH ADDRESS & LOCATION IN RELATION TO SUBJECT Kent HOlle 4901 Airport Pkwy, 344.47' E Addison Rd 1 Blk South George RoddX 4500 blk Sunbelt, ApprO){, 667' W. of Addison Rd 5 blks N. Pat Haggertv 2030 Chenault @Earhart southeast corner ACTUAL SALE PRICE $742.000. $125,000. $530.500. CONDITIONS OF SALE Cash Cash Cash ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE $3.10 $2.76 $3.00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA CURRENT USAGE Federal Express Distribution Facilitv Unimproved Warehouse under Construction HIGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Commercial Commereial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale sale None at sale None at sale Correlation ofComparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $..w12""9"".5:::L40",,.___ Form 200la Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTI JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION: __________ Estimated remaining economic life ofimprovements,,,,,2,,,5-,y.,,ea,,,r,..s_____________ _ Stabilized Gross Income.......... , .. ,"',., ........... , .. , ........ ,$ 21,000, Vacancy 15 % ................................. ,.......... 3,150. Effective Gross Income...................... , ............... " .... " ............................... ,', ................. , ......... $17,850, Taxes: City, ............................... , ................................... ',' .$_-=--_ State & County .... : .................... } ............................ $ -0Miscellaneous (School, etc,) ............... , ...... , ............. $___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage ...................................... $ 69, Misce!laneous,... ", .................... ", .............. , ........ ,".$:---:7:' Annual Deferred Maintenance ...................... .............. $ 300. Management 4 % ...................................... $ 714 Operating Expenses ..Uti1ities..................................... $ 863, Other Expenses ,.......................... ....$___ Total Expenses before Depreciation ........... , ............................................................................ $ 1,946. Net Income to Property ....................... , ...... " ...... " ................................................................... $ 15,904, , Less Income Attributable to (Land) ............................ $129,540. @10,5 % .................... $ 13,602, Income Attributable to (Improvements) ., ..... , ...... " .............................................. , .................... $ 2,302. Income Capitalized@""1",,2__% ('--__% Interest___% for Recapture of Capital) ..... $ 19,183, (Land) (Improvements) ", ....... " ............... , ... ', ..,.,., .............. ' .... ,," ........ ,', .... " ....... ".,., ............. ,$129,540. ====:::: ESTIMATED VALUE BY CAPITALIZATION APPROACH .............................................. $148,723, ADDITIONAL APPRAISAL INFORMATION Form 200 I a Page 6 FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE OF VVHOLE PROPERTY Correlaton ofApproaches to Value See Page 6A Estimated Value ofWhole Property Owner $ Leasehold "'_____ "" ... , .. "., .. , ...... ,.,..... , ...... , .. ,... " .... " .. $____ 6A CORRELATION The City of Addison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement tenninates on December 3 I, 2000. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value of the subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units of comparison derived from sales of similar properties in the marketplace. Those units ofcomparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative ofthe market estimate ofvalue for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis ofthe income stream of the property and comparison of that income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate ofvalue. The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal of substitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value of the site, the reproduction cost of the improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate of value. The market approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land. Sale #1 is located one block south ofthe subject and east of Addison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as AilPort Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north ofthe subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west ofthe subject and on the west side ofAddison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property. These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity ofAddison Airport used for commercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of$3.00 per square fuot is selected as fair market value ofthe land befure the taking for the land taken, and fur the land value after the taking. At $3.00 per square foot the fair market value ofthe land is $129,540. When $3.00 is multiplied times 10,428 square reet, fair market value ofthe land taken for the right of way equals $31,284. 6,365 square feet or 38.25% ofthe building is being taken with a value of$7,337. attributed to this part of the improvements ($19,183. improvement value x 38.25%). The income approach is the most reliable indicator ofvalue ofthe subject. The cost approach indicates an upper limit of value when the improvements are new new and constitute the highest and best use for the property. The income stream generated by the property can be compared to income from other investments available in the market with similar and varied degrees ofrisk and durability. Direct capitalization -building 􀁲􀁾􀀮􀁩􀁤􀁵􀁡􀁬􀀠technique is used to estimate the value ofthe property under the income approach. The land va. .'las been established at $129,540. from c larable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate return on the value of the land or $13,602. When this income is subtracted from net income to property, $2,302. of income is attributed to the improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to the improvements of$19,183. The sums ofthe value ofland and value ofthe improvements equals the estimated value ofthe whole property of $148,723. The income approach is the most accurate estimate ofthe fair market value. Therefore, $148,723. is the fair market value of the subject before the taking. The value of the remaiuder before the taking is $1l0,102. ($148,723. less $38,621.). After the taking, the improvements are reduced by 6,365 square feet, leaving approximately 10,725 square feet. The remaining improvements will generate income on a prorata basis equivalent equivalent to income generated before the taking. Therefore, the value of the remainder after the taking is unchanged and is equal to $110,102. In addition to taking a portion ofthe improvements and the right ofway, a temporary construction easement will be taken. This easement will be needed for a period oftwo years and that compensation will be equal to 10.5% ofthe fair market value ofthe land for that period (1,400 sq. ft. x $3 x 10.5% x 2 yrs. = $882.). Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $ 7,337. Right ofWay Taken 31,284. $38,621. Construction Easement Taken 882. Total Just Compensation $39,503. Form 200la Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKlNG Legal Description Part Taken ________________________ Dimensions x = 10.428. Sq.Ft. .2394 Acres WHOLE PROPERTY: The market value ofthe whole property is ................. $148.723. PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is:........................................................................................ $38.621. (I) REMAINING PROPERTY: The market value ofthe remiander inunediately before the taking is:.............................................................. $ 110.102. (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder immediately after the taking is:................................... $ J 10.102. (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany ................................................................................ ................... $_..:;-0£:.-__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, ifany...............................................................................􀀤􀀧􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀭􀁣􀁾􀀭􀁏􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀭__ TOTAL COMPENSATION............................................................. , ................. $38,621. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of Part Taken Airplane Storage Remainder Before Taking _S""am"""e'--___-.,..::-::--::-__________ Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected,---'S"'a"'m.,e'--________________ Contributory Remainder Remainder VaJueof Part Taken Before After Improvements Taking Taking Bldg.-6,365 (38.25%) 7,337. 11,846. 11,846. TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS 11.846. RIGfITOFWAY $31,284. $ 98.256. iii 98,25g. 10,428 s.f. @$3. TOTAL AS A UNIT $38,621. (1) $110,102. (2) $110,102. (3) )'. " i . CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + 882. $39,503. Fonn 2001a Page 8 #1 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMEN 1 􀁾􀀭􀀧􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀠􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀮􀀮􀀠􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀠 Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd, Grantee 􀁍􀁾􀀻􀁭􀀮􀀮􀀬􀀡􀁤􀁜􀀱􀁾_____________ Dated_--"10""/=-3""1I..<.94"-______Recorded in Volume,...;9"'4""2-<'10"--_____ Local Address 490 I Airport Parkwav Legal Description Abst. 482. Tract 30. Addison. TX Actual Price $742.000. Verified Conditions Rentai,,",c_________________________________ Land Size 5.4963 Acres Unit Price: As Imprc1vel:L _____;· Unimprovcd...$"'3o...1"'0'--___ Street Curb 8: Gutter Improvments None at sale Size and Description, __-:-::-_-::-_-:_--;-;-::--:_--;;:--:-:-_--;;:-:-__-:::--:-:-:____ Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance ofthe tract ofwhich Condition and DesirabilitY--,t",h",is",i",s-"a...􀁰􀀢􀀬􀁡􀀡􀀮􀀡􀁲􀁴􀁾􀀮______________________ Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best 􀁕􀁓􀀧􀁬􀁟􀀮􀀮􀁑􀀲􀀡􀀡􀁬􀁬􀀡􀁬􀀡� �􀀡􀁾􀀡􀁌_______ Date Inspected 7 /15/95 􀁚􀁯􀁮􀁩􀁮􀁧􀁾􀁃􀀢􀀢􀀢􀀢􀁯􀁯􀁭􀁭􀁷􀁵􀀢􀀧􀁥􀀢􀀧􀁲􀁣􀀧􀀢􀁪􀁡􀀢􀀧􀁉􀁟􀁟􀀧􀀭􀁉􀀧􀀭􀀭__________ -Use reverse side for other pertinent infonnation, ___-::;;:-__--;_-:_-:-____-,._ 􀁁􀁾􀁴􀁌􀀯􀀴􀀩􀀯􀁩􀁦􀁩􀁩􀁉􀁦􀀺􀁻􀀠 Appraiser Form 200 la Page 8 #2 ==c-------COMPARABLE SALES .DArA_SJDf'EL,EM!El'!..!='7. Sales Parties: Grantor M& F Development Co.. Inc. Grantee Manufacturing Dated 3/21195 Recorded in Volume.-"9""S",0),,,·)" --______ Page _4"'6.,,3'--__ Local Address 4S00 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description 􀁗􀁥􀁳􀁴􀁾􀀻􀀧􀀠_ Tract \3 Sunbelt Business Park Addition, Addison, TX Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀱􀀢􀀢􀀲􀀢� �􀀵􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀬􀁏􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀁾􀀮________Verified With George Roddv Conditions of Salc--"C"'a"'sh"-______.._____________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁮􀁬􀁾􀁾􀁾___________________________________________ Land Size 1.0382 Acres Unit Price: As Improved________; Unimproved $2,76 Street Concrete Curb &c'G"u"'tt""e. Fencing "'___􀁾􀀠Walks $ . Drives $ .......................................................... ............... " ... $.___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property ..... ""................""""......"""................ $241,452. LAND............. 40,560 square feet ""$3"".0"'0'--__ per.sq.ft .................................................. $121,680. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH ........................................................................ $363.132. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Building is approximately 15 yrs. old. Reasonable wear and tear is estimated at 40%. Remaining economic life is approximately 25 yrs. MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY (Land Comparables) Purchase Price of Subject Property $,-------Date'_________ Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information ofComparable Properties SALE NO. 2 3 SALE DATE 10/31/94 3121195 04117195 Hope Invt. Ltd. M&F Development Co Chaiu Chin 􀁇􀁒􀁊􀁕􀁦􀁔􀁏􀁒􀁾􀁒􀁁􀁎􀁔􀁅􀁅􀀠Addison. Ltd. Diversco Mann AER SALE CONFIRMED WITH Kent HOlle George 􀁒􀁑􀁤􀁤􀁾􀀠Pat Haggem 4901 Airport Pkwy, 4500 blk Sunbelt, 2030 Chenault @ADDRESS & LOCATION 344.47' E Addison Rd Approx. 667' W. of Earhart southeast IN RELATION TO SUBJECT 1 Blk South Addison Rd 5 blks N. comer ACTUAL SALE PRICE $742.000. $125,000. $530.500. CONDITIONS OF SALE Cash Cash ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE $3.10 $2.76 $3.00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA Federal Express Warehouse under CURRENT USAGE Distribution Facility Unimproved Construction HIGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Conunercial CQrnrnercial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale None at sale None at sale "Correlation of Comparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $ 121.680. Fonn 200la Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION: SUbject is under a ground lease with original 40 yr terin. The lease has approximatelv 23 yrS and 3 mo. remaining. Net income from building is capitalized at 12%. Return on land value is 1O.5%. Estimated remaining economic life of improvements,-'2"'5c.:y"'e""ar..."s'----______________ Stabilized Gross Income ............................................ $ 41.520. Vacancy 15 %............................................ 6.228. Effective Gross Income ................................. .......................................................................... $35,292, Taxes: City ... """ ..",... , .... "., ........ , .......... , ............. , ...... " .... $ ___ State & County .......... , ................... , ..................... , ..$.___ Miscellaneous (School, etc.) ................................. , ..$___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage ...................................... $ 224. Miscellaneous.., ... , ..... ,:" .............. " ....... , .............. , ..$__:-:-:Annual Deferred Maintenance .................................... $ 600. Management 4 % ...................................... $ 1.412. Operating Expenses ..Utilities ..................................... $ IAOO. Other Expenses ...............................$.___ Total E){penses before Depreciation .., ................................... , ................... , .. , ... , ........ , ............. $ 3,676, Net Income to Property ....... , .................... , .............................................................................. $ 31,656. Less Income Attributable to (Land) ............................. $121,680. @10.5 % .................... $ 12,776. Income Attributable to (Improvements) .................................................. , ................................ $ 18,880. Income Capitalized@.21.=.2__% L(__% Interest. ___% for Recapture ofCapital) ..... $157,333. (Land) (Improvements) .......................................................... , ..................... , .......................... $121,640. ESTIMATED VALUE BY CAPITALIZATION APPROACH .............................................. $279,013. Discounted Cash Flow (Say) $279,000. ADDITIONAL APPRAISAL INFORMATION Form 200la Page 6 FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE OF WHOLE PROPERTY Corrclaton ofApproaches to Value See Page 6A Estimated Value of Whole Property Owner $ Leasehold $_____.................................... ...................$,____ : Page6A ! The City of Addison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement terminates on December 31, 2000. Several ground leases extend beyond that date. This property is under a ground lease with an original term offorty years, as of November I, 1995. Twenty three (23) years, three (3) months remain on the lease. '. For purposes of this report, it is assumed that the property is owned and operated by the fee owner. The fair market value estimated herein does not attempt to determine the value of the leased fee, the sublease position (sandwich position) ofthe airport management or the leasehold estate created by the lease for the tenant currently in possession ofthe property. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value of the subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units ofcomparison derived from sales ofsimilar properties in the marketplace. Those units of comparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range of values which should be indicative ofthe market estimate of value for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis ofthe income stream of the property and comparison ofthat income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate of value. The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal of substitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value ofthe site, the reproduction cost of the improvements less. any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue. The market approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land. Sale # I is located one block south ofthe subject and east of Addison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north ofthe subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west ofthe subject and on the west side ofAddison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property. These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity ofAddison Airport used for commercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of$3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market value ofthe land before the taking for the land taken, and for the land value after the taking. At $3.00 per square foot the fair market value of the land is $121,680. When $3.00 is multiplied times 3,515 square feet, fair market value of the land taken for the right ofway equals $10,545. 3,610 square feet or 23.59% of the building is being taken with a value of$37,114. attributed to this part of the improvements ($157;333. improvement value x 23.59%). The income approach is the most reliable indicator ofvalue of the subject. The cost approach indicates an upper limit ofvalue when the improvements are new and constitute the highest and best use for the property. ;... The income stream generated bv 􀁴􀁾􀁥􀀠property can be compared to income from other investmcnts available in the market with similar and \ hl degrees ofrisk and durability. Direct capitalization -building residual technique is used to estimate the value of the property under the income approach. The land value has been established at $121,680. from comparable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate rerum on the value ofthe land or $12,776. When this income is subtracted from net income to property, $18,880. ofincome is attributed to the improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to the improvements of $157,333. The sums ofthe value ofland and value of the improvements equals the estimated value ofthe whole property of$279,000. The income approach is the most accurate estimate of the fair market value. Therefore $279,000 is the fair market value ofthe subject befure the taking. The value of the remainder before the taking is $231,354. ($279,013. less $47,659.). After the taking, the improvements are reduced by 3,610 square feet or 23.59% leaving approximately 11,690 square feet. The remaining improvements will generate income on a promta basis equivalent to income generated before the taking. Therefure, the value ofthe remainder after the taking is unchanged and is equal to $231,254. In addition to taking a portion of the improvements and the right of way, a temporary construction easement will be taken. This easement will be needed for a period oftwo years and that compensation will be equal to 10.5% ofthe fair market value ofthe land for that period (1,100 sq. ft. x $3 x 10.5% x 2 yrs. "" $693.). Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $37,114. Right ofWay Taken 10,545. $47,659. Construction Easement Taken 693. Total Just Compensation $48,352. 􀁾􀀠: Fonn 200la Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKING Legal Description Part Taken _________________________ Dimensions x -3,797 􀁓􀁱􀀬􀁆􀁴􀀮􀀮􀁾􀀬􀀢􀀧􀀰􀁟􀀢􀁟􀀸􀀶􀀢􀀧􀀷􀀧􀁟􀁟________Acres WHOLE PROPERTY: The market value ofthe whole property is ",,,,,,.,,,,,,,.$279.013 PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is:"""""""""'''''"."'''''''''"'''''"''"."''''".,,,,."'''''"'''''''''''",$47,659, (I) REMAINING PROPERTY: The market value ofthe remiander inunediately before the taking is:"".""""'''"''''''''''',,",,"",,,,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.$ 23 1.354, (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder inunediately after the taking is:.""""""""".".""."".,,$ 231354. (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany"", ",,,""",",."", '" ".,,' "'" """"""""""""".".,,"".,,"""" '" """".$,_..:;-0",,-__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, ifany"", """""".",,, "'" """.""""""".,,""""""""""""."$_",,-0,,,,-__ TOTAL COMPENSATION", ".,"", ". """ "" "",",,"""","""""".. ",,"""."".".".$47,659. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of Part Taken Aimlane Storage 􀁒􀁥􀁭􀁡􀁩􀁮􀁤􀁥􀁲􀁂􀁥􀁦􀁵􀁲􀁥􀁔􀁡􀁫􀁩􀁮􀁧􀁟􀁓􀁾􀁡􀁭􀁾􀁥􀁾􀁾___􀁾􀁾___________ Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected _____________________ Contributory Value of Improvements Part Taken Remainder Before Taking Remainder After Taking Bldg,-3,6 IO (23.59%) and Concrete Paving approx, 37, II4 120,219 120,219 TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS RlGHTOFWAY LAND 3,515 s.f. @$3 10,545, $II 1,135, TOTAL AS A UNIT $47,659. (I) $231,354. (2) $231,354. (3) CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + 693, $48,352. Form 200la Page 8 #1 COMPARABLESALESDATASUPPLEMEN, 􀁾􀀭􀀮􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀧􀀢􀁾􀁾􀀮􀀠􀀭􀀮􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀽􀀠Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd. Grantee Addison Ltd. Dated__lO/31/94 _____ Recorded in Volume,"'9"'4"'2"'I"'O'-_____ Page 3570 Local Address 4901 Airport Parkwav Legal Description Abst 482. Tract 30. Addison. TX Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀢􀀭􀀷􀀭􀀭􀀬􀀴� �􀀬􀀲􀀮􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀬􀁏􀁏􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀮􀁾_______Verified With,-,K"e",n"'-t􀀬􀀬􀀢􀁈􀀡􀀮􀁜􀀬􀁯􀁾􀁰􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁥___________ Conditions Rental Date________________________________ Land Size 5.4963 Acres ..____ Unit Price: As Irnproved,______; Unimproved,"'$""3"'.I..,O'--___ _______________ Utilities________Street__-,C"u",rb""",&"->,G""u""tt,,,erc.. Improvrnents None at sale Size and Description__-c=_-::__-:-_-:-:-:--;-_-:;-_-:--:-_-c=___::--:-:--:-____ Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance ofthe tract of which Condition and Desirability this is a part .. _______________________ Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best 􀁕􀁳􀁥􀁟􀀭􀀧􀁃􀁏􀁾􀁭􀁭􀀢􀀢􀀢􀀢􀀧􀁥􀁲􀀮􀀮􀀬􀁣􀀢􀀧􀁩􀁡􀀢􀀧􀁉_________ Date Inspected-'7.J../Jc!)""'1""9""5__________ 􀁚􀁯􀁮􀁩􀁮􀁧􀁾􀁬􀀱􀀱􀀢􀀧􀁭􀀢􀀧􀁥􀀢􀀧􀀭􀁲􀀢􀀧􀁣􀁬􀀢􀀧􀂷􀁡􀀢􀀭􀁉􀀭􀁟􀀧􀁉___________ Use reverse side fur other pertinent information ___________-;-___-;--;-_ /'i . /f7 I .:.:: ././􀁖􀀻􀀻􀁤􀁾􀂣􀀠􀀤􀀭􀀣� �􀀿􀁌􀁾􀁻􀀠! Appraiser Fonn 200 I a Page 8 #2 Sales Parties: Grantor M& F Development Co .. Inc. Grantee Manufacturing Dated 3/21/95 _______ Recorded in Volume.-,9",S""0,,,S),:.'______Page -'4"'6""3'--__ Local Address 4500 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description West y, . Tract 13 Sunbelt Business Park ..􀀬􀀭􀁁􀀢􀀬􀁤􀀢􀀢􀁤􀁬􀀻􀀮􀁣􀂷􀁴􀁩􀀢􀀬􀁯􀀢􀀬􀁮􀀮􀁾􀁁􀀬􀀭􀀬􀁤􀀢􀀬􀁤􀀢􀀬􀁩􀀢􀀬􀁳􀁯􀀢􀀢􀁮􀀢􀀢􀀧􀀮􀁊􀀮􀁔􀀢􀀢􀁘� �􀀭􀀭_______ Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀢􀀱􀀢􀀢􀀲􀀵􀀢􀀬􀀮􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀬􀁏􀀮􀁾_______Verified With George Roddv Conditions of Sale--'C"'a"'s"'h____________________________ Rental Date_____􀁾__________________________ Land Size 1.0382 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____; Unimproved $2.76 Street COl!crete Curb & Gutter __________ Utilities,--£A"'IlL-__ ImprO\ments None at Sale Size and Description_l.,evel, readv for development Condition and Desirability___________________________ Current Use Unimproved Highest and Best Use Light Industrial & Commercial Date Inspected_7u.1"'15"'1"'9"'S"'S________ Zoning Commercial -I Use reverse side for other pertinent infonnation, _______________-:-..-___ 􀁡􀁾􀀴􀁁􀁊􀁀􀁩􀁬􀁬Appraiser ... . Fonn 20013 Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMEl', Appraiser Form 200 I a Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT Sales Parties: Grantor 􀀭􀀢􀀬􀁃􀀢􀀬􀁨􀀬􀀬􀁾􀁩􀀡􀀮􀁩􀁵􀁌􀁃􀁾􀁬􀁬􀁉􀀡􀀮􀁃􀂷􀁮􀁌􀀭___________ Grantee _A"""E"'R'--______ Dated 4114/95 ________ Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀬􀀬􀀹􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀵􀀰􀁾􀀷􀂣􀀺􀀺􀀴􀀬􀀭􀀭_____ Page -'£66"'8'--__ Local Address 2030 Chenoult, 􀁃􀁮􀁲􀁲􀁯􀁬􀁬􀁴􀁑􀀧􀁬􀀱􀀡􀀱􀁾􀀬T-'-"'X'--____________________ Legal Descriptioll -Abstract 􀀹􀀲􀀳􀀮􀁾􀁔􀀮􀀡􀀮􀀧􀀭􀀧􀁲􀁡􀀢􀀬􀁣􀀢􀁴􀀭􀀽􀀲􀀢􀀬􀁏_______________________ Actual Price--1»,,",'􀀳􀀻􀁣􀁏􀀬􀀭􀀾􀀮􀀢􀀭􀁓􀁏􀀢􀀬􀁏􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀬􀁾________Verified With Pot Haggertv Conditions ofSalc-'C"",,"'s"-hL-_____________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁵􀁬􀁾􀀢􀀮􀀬􀀬__________________________,__________ Land Size---.:lJ),"-S9"'2"-'..A"'c"'re"'s'--______ Unit Price: As Improved______: Unimproved $3,00 Street Concrete Ctlfb & Gutter __________ Utilities--'-'A"'lI____ 􀁉􀁭􀁰􀁲􀁯􀁜􀀱􀁔􀁉􀁥􀁮􀁾􀀠􀁎􀁯􀁮􀁥􀁡􀁴􀁓􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁥__________􀁾__􀁾_________􀁾_______ Size and Description___________________________________ Condition and Desirability_______________ Current Use Warehouse under constmciton Highest and Best !Jse.-,C",o"m",mci!e",r""e",ia'!..l_______ Date Inspected----CI""O/"'2"'2'-'./9"'Sc-______ Zoning Commercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent infonllation ___ 0:---------______--;-___ 􀁻􀀻􀀡􀀻􀁣􀁾􀁊􀀺􀀠A [!li/tL I Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority Fonn 200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number ___-c-_____ Address Hanger T -6, Keller Sorings Owner City ofAddison Address_____________ Occupant's Name _________ Whole Takin.,.,g___Partial Taking X Purpose ofthe Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subject property as of 12/20/95 It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and' damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein will be used fur settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered for sale by one who desires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation In my opinion the compensation due as a result ofthis taking is: Owner $133,604, Leasehold Interest $ ______ Total $133,604, Appraiser's Certificate I hereby certify that the opmlOn of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful 'examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I wi!! immediately notify the Authority of such interest or interests, UmL !4J;//tJI, Appraiser Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-Wa Fonn 100 la Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTfNENT PICTURES Parcel No. _____ Local Address HANGER T-i>, KELLER SPRINGS Date Taken ___1:.;2",,1-,1-,,0-,-1-<-9,,-5_ ___ Taken by __. CHARLES ..i!l.Ql..-'MuI""LbLLE ""R'--______ L Point from wruch taken _____...._EAST _SIDE ....__________._ Looking _ -"W"'E"'S-'-T____ .. ; i 2. Point from wruch taken __..;;W"'Ec::S"'T..cS"'I"'D"'E'--_______ Looking_--""EA"'S'-'T '--___ Form 200la Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description,_---"A"'b"'st"'ra""ct"-L79"-'Z"",J;A"d"'dw;is"'io""n'-.!M"""un"'i""cl",'p"'al""A!.l!.Lim"'o"'rt"-_____________ Dimensions: 130 feet x -±:ZO""4'--____ feet =26,5Z0 sq.ft. .6088 Acres Location (Urban): Street & No. _________-:--____on________.side between -:::=---::-_____________and ____________streets. (Rural): _____".--:-::----=________________ ::-:-:-:-::---:---:---;-_-;--;--;--= Land Grant Survey ---:--:-:-----;-:-c:---:-::----:---:----Neighborhood or Area Analysis: The Neighborhood is a commercial and industrial area, having restaurant, neighborhood service, office, office showroom and warehouse facilities. A major asset in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation. The subject is located on Airport property. Highest and Best Use and Zoning of Subject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial-3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: 7,556 ft.@$Z3.00 per square foot ............... $173,788. Parking Lot: $1.15 per sQuare ft .. 18,964sq.ft ................. $ 21,809. Total Reproduction ...................................... : ......................................................... $195,597. Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration .......................... 40%....................................... $ 78.239. Functional Obsolescence : ................................................................... $ -0Economic Obsolescence .......................... ........................................... $ -0Total Depreciation ................................................................................................... $ 78.239. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property .......................................................................... $117,358. Garages: ft.@$perft.......................................................$ .___ Less Depreciation ................................................................................................. $ Other (Detail).............................................................. .............................................$__ Less Depreciation .................................................................................................. $ $___ $,___ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $,__=-:-", Fencing 􀁾___􀁾􀀠Walks $ ,Drives $ ...............................................................................$___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property ............................................................. $117.358. LAND ............. 26,520 square feet !lC$3"-'.:.O>!.\,O!....-__ per.sq.ft ..................................... ........... $ 79,560. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH ..................................................................... $196.918. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Form 200la Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY (Land Comparables) Date,_________Purchase Price of Subject Property $,------Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information of Comparable Properties SALE NO, 2 3 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10/31/94 Hope Invt. Ltd. Addison. Ltd. 3121/95 M&F Development Co Diversco Mann 04/17/95 Chaiu Chin AER SALE CONFIRMED WITH KentHQQe George RQddy Pat Haggerty ADDRESS & LOCATION IN RELATION TO SUBJECT 4901 Airport Pkwy, 344.47' E Addison Rd I Blk South 4500 blk SunbeJt, Approx.667'VV.of Addison Rd 5 blks N. 2030 Chenault @Earhart southeast corner ACTUAL SALE PRICE $742.000. $125,000. $530,500. CONDITIONS OF SALE Casb Cash Casb ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE $3,10 $2.76 $3,00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA CURRENT USAGE Federal Express Distribution Facility 􀁾􀁕􀁮􀁩􀁭􀁑􀁲􀁯􀁶􀁥􀁤􀀠VVarebouse under Construction HIGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Commercial Commercial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale None at sale None at sale Correlation ofCornparable Sales To Subject Property: , , .. Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value of Market Data Approach $'...l72,9,,,,5,,,60,,,-.__􀁾􀀠 Fonn 200la Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METIIOD OF CAPITALIZATION:_________ Estimated remaining economic life of improvements....2""5-: :: ..... Direct capitalization -building 􀁲􀁰􀀮􀁾􀁩􀁤􀁵􀁡􀁬􀀠technique is used to estimate the vallJe ofthe property under the income approach. The land 􀁶􀁾􀀠lhas been established at $79,560. from cc irable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate return on the value ofthe land or $8,384. When this income is subtracted from net income to property, $14,464. of income is attributed to the improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to the improvements of $120,533. The sums ofthe value ofland and value ofthe improvements equals the estimated value ofthe whole property of$200,093. The income approach is the most accurate estimate of the fair market value. Therefore $200,093 is the fair market value ofthe subject before the taking. The value ofthe remainder before the taking is $77,413. ($200,093. less $122,680.). After the taking, the improvements are completely removed. $120,533. is the value attributed to the improvements. The value ofthe remainder after the taking is unchanged and is equal to $77,415. In addition to taking ofthe improVIDents and the surface easement, a temporary construction easement will be taken. It is estimated that this easement will be needed for a period of two years and that compensation will be equal to 10.5% ofthe fair market value ofthe land for that period (17,340 sq.ft. x $3. x 10.5% x 2 yrs. = $10,924). Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $120,553. llight ofWay Taken 2,127. $122,680. Construction Easement 10,924. Taken Total Just Compensation $133,604. Form 200la Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKING Legal Description Part Taken ________________________ Dimensions x = Sq.Ft.___________Acres WHOLE PROPERTY: The market value ofthe whole property is ..H............. $200,093. PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is: ... H ... H .. H ................. H .......HHHm ...H., .... H ..,......HHH., .... ., .. .$122,680. (I) REMAmmG PROPERTY: The market value of the remiander immediately before the taking is:.......,H................HH ......HH ..HH....... HH ... .,$ 77,413. (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be SUbjected to, the market value ofthe remainder immediately after the taking is:... HHH ..,............ H .........$ 77.413. (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany HH ...HH ....HHH..........HH.H .........HHH ......... HH ...........HHH .........HH ... $ __-O:'-"__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, ifany .......................... H ... H...........HH .... H H .. HHH.HHH .. HHHH$=-.::;-0";O";:-_ TOTAL COMPENSATION. H.HH HH"H'" HH" .....HH HHHH" .......H'HH. H" H'HHHHH... $122, 180. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAmDER Highest and Best Use of 􀁐􀁡􀁲􀁴􀁔􀁡􀁫􀁥􀁮􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾_____________________ Remainder Before Taking -;-;--:_-:-__-;-:-:-- ;-__________ Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected,_____________________ Contributory Remainder Remainder Value of Part Taken Before After Improvements Tiling Tiling Bldg.-7,556 sf(100%) 120.553 TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS 120,553. : ." RIGHT OF WAY 2,127. 77.413. 77,413. . 709 sf @$3 , 􀁾􀀠 TOTAL AS A UNIT $122,680. (1) $ 77,413. (2) $ 77,413. (3) CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + 10,924. $133,604. Fonn 200 la Page 8 #1 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMEN"l 􀁾􀁾􀀭􀁾􀀭􀀭􀁾􀀢􀀭􀀺􀀧􀀺􀀺􀀧􀀮􀀺-..􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀁾􀀽􀀠Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd. Grantee Addison Ltd. Dated._--2C1O""1""3"'1I.L9:c4______ Recorded in Vo!ume..,,9"'4"'21'-'0'--_____ Page 3570 Local Address 490 I Airport Parkwav Legal Description Abst. 482. Tract 􀀺􀁬􀁏􀀧􀁌􀁟􀀧􀀭􀀧􀁁􀁴􀁽􀁃􀁤􀀾􀁬􀀮 􀀡􀁤􀁤􀀮􀀡􀁩􀁾􀁳􀁯􀁤􀀮􀀡􀁮􀁨􀀭􀀮􀀮􀀮􀀻􀁔􀀮􀁌􀁘􀁾__________________ Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀢􀀤􀁃􀀡􀀮􀀷􀀢􀀬􀀴􀀲􀀢􀀬􀀬􀁟􀀮􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁏􀁏􀀬􀀬􀀢􀀮􀁾_______Verified Witb--"-K"'e"'nt>-H"-"'o"pe"--_________ _ Conditions 􀁯􀁦􀁓􀁡􀁬􀁥􀁾􀁃􀁤􀁡􀀡􀀻􀀾􀁳􀀮􀀡􀁬􀁨____________________________ Rental Date ________________________________ Land Size 5.4963 Acres Unit Price: As Improved_____; Unimproved."'$""3"'".1. ..,O'--__ Street__􀁾􀁃􀀮􀀺􀀱􀁵􀀡􀁌􀁲􀁢􀀡􀁌􀀲􀀦􀀢􀀭􀁇􀁬􀀮􀀸􀀡􀁕􀁬􀁬􀁴􀁴􀀡􀁩􀀡􀁥􀁲􀀧􀁟􀁟_______________ Utilities________ . Improvrnents None at sale Size and Description,__--::-::-_-::-_--:_--:-:-:--: -_--::----:--:-_--::-:-__-::--:-:-:-____ Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance oftbe tract ofwhich Condition and Desirability--,t",h",is"",i",s..,a...p",a",rtO-'______________________ Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facility Highest and Best 􀁕􀁳􀁥􀁟􀀮􀀮􀀾􀀮􀁃􀀢􀀧􀁯􀀢􀀧􀁭􀁭􀁾􀁥􀀢􀀧􀁲􀁣􀀢􀀧􀁩􀀢􀀢􀁡􀁬􀀧􀁟􀁟_______ Date 􀁉􀁮􀁳􀁰􀁥􀁣􀁴􀁥􀁤􀀬􀀭􀀭􀀬􀀷􀀢􀀭􀀱􀀢􀀬􀀬􀀱􀀵􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀯􀁾􀀹􀀵􀀬􀀬􀀭 _________ Zoning .... Commercial-I -Use reverse side for other pertinent infonnation ____________-,-___-,,-, -£,i //J ) v.. j? 􀁉􀀧􀀺􀀺􀀢􀁾􀀯􀁌􀀺􀀧􀀠􀁊􀁾􀀧􀀯􀀠􀁨􀀯􀁾􀁴􀁾􀀠Appraiser Foml 200la Page 8 #2 ;;;;;c:-:-;:::;:::::. .,.. ____􀁾􀁾􀀧􀁌􀀮􀁖􀁬􀁖􀁬􀁴􀀧,'\K1'U>i,C SALES.. DATA 􀁾􀀢􀀧􀁊􀁊􀀮􀁴􀀺􀁴􀀺􀁬􀀬􀀠􀁃􀁉􀁹􀀧􀀧􀁬􀁊􀀺􀀺􀀧􀁬􀁾􀁌􀁬􀁾􀀠Sales Parties: Grantor M& F Development Co .. Inc ..._____ Grantee Manufacturing Dated 3121/95 Recorded in Volume-<9"'S'"'0)"'-S'--_____Page -'4"'6""3'--__ Local Address 4500 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description West Yo. . Tract 13 Sunbelt Business.Park Addition. Addison. TX Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀭􀀭􀀾􀁦􀀤􀀢􀀱􀀢􀀧􀀲􀀵􀁾􀀮􀀬􀀬􀁏􀁙􀀮􀀮􀀰􀀰􀀢􀀧􀀬􀁾___􀁾_____Verified With GeorQe Roddv Conditions ofSale-"C"'a""sh!.L_ _____________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁶􀁾􀀬􀁾_________________________􀁾________ Land Size 1.0382 Acres Unit Price: As lmproved_____; Unimproved $2,76 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter _______ Utilities,---,A",l""l___ Improvments None at Sale Size and Description LeveL ready 􀁦􀁯􀁲􀀮􀀮􀀻􀁤􀀢􀀧􀁥􀀢􀀢􀁶􀁥􀀢􀀧􀁉􀀢􀀧􀁯􀁐􀁬􀀧􀁊􀁭􀁬􀀡􀀡􀁓􀁩􀀡􀁥􀁮􀀡􀁬􀀡􀁴􀁾____________________ Condition and Desirability ___________________________ Current 􀁕􀁳􀁥􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀢􀁕􀀢􀀧􀁮􀁾􀁩􀁭􀀡􀀡􀁊􀁐􀀢􀀧􀁲􀀢􀀢􀁯􀀭􀀧􀀮􀁶􀁥􀀢􀀧􀁤􀀢􀁟_______ Highest and 􀁂􀁥􀁾􀁴􀀠Use Light Industrial & Commercial Date Inspected_7u/""15"'1""9::.S::.S________ Zoning Commercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent information_ . _________:--,--__ --"7"C,.--AJ/#b1L , Appraiser Form 200la Page 8 #3 COMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT Sales Parries: Grantor 􀁾􀁃􀀡􀀡􀁨􀁡􀀼􀀡􀀡􀁩􀀢􀀢􀁵􀁾􀁃􀀢􀀬􀁨􀁬􀀡􀁩􀁮􀀬􀀬􀀭___________ Grantee 􀁾􀁁􀁯􀀮􀁅􀀢􀀢􀁒􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀭______ Dated 4/14195 Recorded in Volume 95074 _____ Page ...:6""6,,,8__ Local Address 2030 Chenault. Carrollton. TX Legal Description Abstract 923. Tract 20 Actual Price $530,500. _____Verified With Pat HaQQertv Conditions of Sale--'C"'a"'s""h___________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁟􀀮_____________________________________ Land Size 4.0592 Acres Unit Price: As lmproved_____; Unimproved $3.00 Street Concrete Curb & Gutter Utilitics-"'A"'ll____ Improvments-..NQ,...􀁮􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁥􀁾􀁡􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁴"Sa"'I"'e____ Size and Descriptioll____________________________________________ Condition and Desirability _____________________________________________ Current Use' Warehouse.under constmciton Highest and Best 􀁹􀁳􀁥􀀬􀁾􀁃􀀼􀀮􀁜􀁯􀀮􀀡􀁌􀁭􀁲􀁮􀁾􀁥􀁬􀁩􀀺􀀡􀁲􀀢􀀧􀁣􀀡􀀡􀀧􀁩􀁡􀀢􀁟􀁬__________ ___ Date Inspected-'1"'0'-'12"'21L9".,5'-__________ Zoning Commercial-l l Use reverse side for other pertinent inforrnation. _____""7____________________􀁾􀁟􀀬􀀮7 /II h I 􀀧􀁾􀀧􀀷􀀠//i.//c?,,??u/i7X .i!E::lZ:r Appraiser Texas Turnpike Authority Form 200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL REPORT Parcel Number _________ Address Hanger T -4. Keller Springs Dallas, Texas Address_____________Owner City of Addison Occupant's Name _________ Whole Taking, ____ Partial Taking X Purpose ofthe Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subject property as of 12/20/95 It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and derense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein wi!! be used for settlement of such claims through negotiation or eminent domain proceedings. Market Value may be defined as follows: "Market Value is the price which the property would bring when it is offered offered for sale by one who desires, but is not obliged, to se!!, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future." Valuation In my opinion the ccmpensation due as a result ofthis taking is: Owner $ 251,417. Leasehold Interest $._______ Total $251,417. Appraiser's Certificate I hereby certify that the oplIlJon of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way ccntingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or any employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notify the Authority of such interest or interests. Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-Wa Fonn 200 la Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No, _______ Local Address HANGER T-4, KELLER SPRI:\GS Date Taken __-<.9LI lw6LlI29'.l5_____ Taken by __C",H"",A""R",L""ES,,-\(...,B,,,OL)..."M" 'r"'L"'LE"'R'-______ 2. Point from which taken ___..!:WE=S-"T-"-SI=-D"'E"--.________ Looking_--"E:;!A:::.ST=-____ Fonn 200la Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal Description Abstract 792, Addison Municipal Aimort Dimensions: 213 feet x -'-11..,0'--____ feet = 23,430 sq.ft. .5379 Acres Location (Urban): Street & No. _________--:-_____on________side bet>veen ---;:::---:::-_____________and ____________streets. (Rural): ______-:-;-_-::-_______________ .,.,-,--:--:--...,---,._-:--::---:-_=_ Land Grant Survey __--,;-:---:-:-:---:-::--:--:--.,----____ Neighborhood or Area Analysis: The Neighborhood is a commercial and industrial area, having restaurant, neighborhood service, office, office showroom and warehouse facilities. A major asset in the area is the Addison Airport, a general aviation operation. The subject is located on Airport property. Highest and Best Use and Zoning of Subject Property: Airplane Storage, Industrial -3 COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: Main Building: 9.139 ft. @$23.00 per square fooL ........... .$210.197. Parking Lot: $1.15 per square ft .. 13,981 sq.ft ............... $ 16,078. Total Reproduction .................................................................................. .............. $226.175. Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration ......................... .40% ....................................... $ 90,470. Functional Obsolescence ................... ................................................. $ -0Economic Obsolescence ..................................................................... $ -0Total Depreciation .............................. ..................................................................... $90,470. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property .......................................................................... $135.705. Garages: ft.@perft.......................................................$,___ Less Depreciation ............................................................................................ ..... $ $,___ Other (Detail).............................................................................................. Detail)..................................................................... ......................... " ............ $ __ Less Depreciation ......................................................................... , ....................... .$ $,___ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $,___..... Fencing $.___􀁾􀀠Walks $ , Drives $ .., .................................... , .. , ................................... $ ___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property ............................................................ $135,705. LAND............. 26,750 square feet ""$3,;.,:.0'i,;0i--__per.sq.ft .......................................... ....... $ 80,250. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH ..................................................................... $215,955. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Building is approximately 15 yrs. old. Reasonable wear and tear is estimated at 40%. Remaining economic life is approximately 25 yrs. 􀁾􀀠.. :- Form 200 I a Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY (Land ComparabJes) Daw_________________Purchase Price of Subject Property $.---------------Improvements Since Purchase and Estimawd Cost Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information of Comparable Properties SALE NO. 2 3 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10/31/94 Hope Invt. Ltd. Addison. Ltd. 3nI195 M&F Development Co Diyersco Mann 04/17/95 Chaiu Chin AER 􀁓􀁁􀁌􀁅􀁃􀁏􀁎􀁆􀁬􀁬􀁕􀁍􀁅􀁄􀁾􀁔􀁈􀀠Kent HOl1e Qeorge Roddv Pat Haggertv 4901 Airport Pkwy, 4500 blk Sunbelt, 2030 Chenault @ADDRESS & LOCATION 344.47' E Addison Rd Approx. 667' W. of Earhart southeast IN RELATION TO SUBJECT I Blk South Addison Rd 5 blks N. comer ACTUAL SALE PRICE $742,000. $125.000. $530.500. CONDITIONS OF SALE Cash Cash Cash ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE $3.10 $2.76 $3.00 LEASE OR RENTAL DATA Federal Express Warehouse under CURRENT USAGE Distribution Facility Unimproved Constnlction HIGHEST & BEST USE Commercial Commercial Commercial SIZE 5.4963 Acres 1.0382 Acres. 4 Acres PHYSICAL FEATURES FEATURES IMPROVEMENTS None at sale None at sale None at sale i ' Correlation of Comparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimared Land Value ofMarket Data Approach $,-"8""0,,.£25,,,0,,-,_____ Form 2001a Page 5 INCOME APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY JUSTIFICATION OF RATE AND METHOD OF CAPITALIZATION: _________ Estimated remaining economic life of 􀁩􀁭􀁰􀁲􀁯􀁶􀁥􀁭􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁳􀀮􀀮􀀡􀀬􀀲􀀢􀀬􀀵􀀭􀁬􀁹􀁾􀁥� �􀀢􀀬􀁲􀀭􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁳_______________ Stabilized Gross Income............................................ $ 35,700. Vacancy 10 %............................................ 3,570. Effective Gross Income........................................................................................................... $32.130. Taxes: City .......................................................... .............. $.___ State & County.......................................................$.___ Miscellaneous (School, etc.) .................................... $.___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage......................................$ 154. Miscellaneous......................................................... $ ___ Annual Deferred Maintenance............................... .....$ 550. Management 4 % ...................................... $ 1,285. Operating Expenses ..Utilities..................................... $ 311. Other Expenses ...............................$._ __ Total Expenses before Depreciation ........................................................................................ $ 2,300. Net Income to Property ........................................ .................................................................. .$ 29.830. Less Income Attributable to (Land) ............................ $ 80,250. @10.5 % .................... $ 8.426. Income Attributable to (Improvements) ................................................................................... $ 21,404. Income Capitalized@,..!1",2__% (L__% Interest.___% for Recapture of CapitaI)..... $I78,367. (Land) (Improvements) ...........................................................................................................$ 80,250. ESTIMATED VALUE BY cAPITALIZATION APPROACH .............................................. $258,617. ADDITIONAL APPRAISAL INFORMAT ION Form 200la Page 6 FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE OF VfHOLE PROPERTY Correlaton ofApproaches to Value See Page 6A Estimated Value ofWhole Property Owncr $ Leasehold "'_____ .............................. .........................$.____ 6A CORRELATION The City of Addison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport ofTexas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property. Unless renewed, this agreement terminates on December 31, 2000. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value ofthe subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units ofcomparison derived from sales ofsimilar properties in the marketplace. Those units ofcomparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative of the market estimate ofvalue for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis ofthe income stream ofthe property and comparison ofthat income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then capitalized at a rate wfiich is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate ofvalue. The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal ofsubstitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue. In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value of the site, the reproduction cost of the improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue. The ma:rket approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land. Sale #1 is located one block south ofthe subject and east ofAddison Road. This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Park\vay connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution facility on this property. Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north ofthe subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse facilities. Sale #3 is west ofthe subject and on the west side ofAddison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse facility is currently under construction on this property. These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity of Addison Airport used for commercial . and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of$3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market value ofthe land before the taking for the land taken, and for the land value after the taking. At $3.00 per square fuot the fair market value ofthe land is $ 80,250. When $3.00 is multiplied times 24,350 square feet, fair market value ofthe land taken for the right ofway equals $73,050. 100% ofthe building is being taken with a value of$178,367. attributed to the improvements. The income approach is the most reliable indicator ofvalue ofthe subject. The cost approach indicates an upper limit ofvalue when the improvements are new and constitute the highest and best use for the property. The income stream stream generated by the property can be compared to income from other investments available in the market with similar and varied degrees ofrisk and durability. Direct capitalization -building TPsidual technique is used to estimate the 􀁶􀁡􀁬􀀢􀁾􀀠ofthe property under the income approach. The land va 'has been established at $80,250. from co. _ .irable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate return on the value ofthe land or $8,426. When this income is subtracted from net income to improvements, $21,404. ofincome is attributed to the improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to the improvements of$I78,367. The sum ofthe value ofland and value of the improvements equals the estimated value ofthe whole property of$258,617. (say $259,000.). The income approach is the most accurate estimate ofthe fair market value. Therefore $259,000 is the fair market value ofthe subject before the taking. The value ofthe remainder ofthe taking is $7,200. ($258,617 less $251,417). After the taking, the improvements are completely removed. 2,400 square feet ofland remain, with a value equal to $7,200. The value ofthe remainder after the taking is unchanged and is equal to $7,200. Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $178,367. Right ofWay Taken 73,050. Total Just Compensation $251,417. Fonn 2001a Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKlNG Legal Description Part Taken _________________________ Dimensions x Sq.Ft.____________ Acres WHOLE PROPERTY: The market value ofthe whole property is ,., .............. $258.617. PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken for highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is:........................................................................................$25 1.417. (1) REMAINING PROPERTY: The market value ofthe remiander immediately before the taking is:.............................................................. $ 7,200. (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder immediately after the taking is: ................................... $ 7.200. (3) NET DAMAGES, if any ................................................................................................. ..$_--'-0:'--__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, if any...............................................................................$::-:-:--=:-O":--=-_ TOTAL COMPENSATION ......... ,', ............ " ............................ , ... ,", ................. $251,417. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of Part Taken Airplane Storage Remainder Before Taking 􀀭􀀭􀀢􀀡􀀧􀁓􀁡􀁭􀁾􀁥􀀢􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭__---,:-:-:,---:-___________ Remainder after taking considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected,---'S"'a"'m"'e'--_________________ Contributory Value of Improvements Part Taken Remainder Before Taking Remainder After Taking Bldg.-9,1395f(100%) and Paving 178,367. -0-0TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS RIGHT OF WAY LAND 24,350 S.F. @$3 73.050. 7.200. 7,200. TOTAL AS A UNIT $251,417. (1) $ 7,200. (2) $ 7,200. (3) Explain difference, if any, benveen Remainder Before and After Taking (If extra space needed, use attachment.) Fonn 200la Page 8 #1 CvM:PARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMEl'< l' 􀁲􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀽􀁾􀀮􀀠􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁾􀀽􀀠Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd. Grantee Addison Ltd. Dated_-''1'''01'''3,,1f-019'''4'--______ Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀮􀁾􀀹􀀢􀀬􀀴􀀢􀀬􀀿􀀢􀀬􀀭􀀱􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀭_____ Page 3570 Local Address 4901 Airport Parkway Legal Description Abst. 482. Tract 30. Addison. TX Actual Price $742.000. Verified With-EK",eG..,u"'tt"e:!..r________________ Utilities________ Improvrnents None at sale Size and 􀁄􀁥􀁳􀁣􀁲􀁩􀁰􀁴􀁩􀁯􀁮􀁾􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀻􀀺􀀺􀀭􀁟􀀭􀀻􀀺􀀺􀀭􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀺􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀭􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀺􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀭􀀭􀁟􀀺􀁟􀁟􀀺􀁟􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀺􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀭􀂭Minor dirt work to aid drainage from balance ofthe tract of which Condition and 􀁄􀁥􀁳􀁩􀁲􀁡􀁢􀁩􀁉􀁩􀁴􀁹􀀭􀀭􀀬􀁴􀁨􀀾􀀮􀀡􀁩􀁬􀁬􀁩􀁳􀀡􀀮􀀱􀁩􀁾􀁳􀀭􀀢􀁡􀀢􀀬􀁰􀀢􀀬􀁡􀁩􀀡􀁊􀁲􀁴􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀮______________________ Current Use Fed Ex Distribution Facilitv Highest and Best Use,_-"C",o",mm=e",r""ci",aLI________ Date Inspected,--'7l-"lS Appraiser Form 200la Page 8 #2 =r.::-::-=-:-:-____.LIJIVllri\J'CAl:'Lt: SALES_DATA'􀁓􀁬􀁬􀀱􀁾􀁾􀁌􀁅􀁍􀁲􀁵􀁊􀁲􀀭􀀽􀀠 Sales Parties: Grantor M& F Development Co.. Inc. Grantee Manufacturing Dated 3/21/95 Recorded in 􀁖􀁯􀁬􀁵􀁭􀁥􀀧􀀭􀀲􀀹􀀢􀀬􀀵􀀢􀀬􀁏􀁾􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀭5'_______ Page -'4"'6".,3'--__ Local Address 4500 Block Sunbelt Drive Legal Description West y" Tract !3 Sunbelt Business Park 􀁁􀁤􀁤􀁩􀁴􀁩􀁯􀁮􀀬􀀮􀁁􀀢􀀢􀁤􀀢􀀬􀁤􀁩􀀢􀀬􀁳􀀢􀀬􀁯􀁮􀀢􀀬􀀬􀁾􀁔􀀬􀀭􀀬􀁘􀀬􀀬􀀭_______ Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀁾􀁓􀀢􀀢􀁉􀀽􀀭􀀲􀀩􀀢􀀬􀀭􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀭􀁏􀁏􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀮􀁾_______Verified With George Roddv Conditions of Sale-'C"'as"'-'-'-h___________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁡􀁬􀁶􀁡􀁾______________________ __________ Land Size 1.0382 Acres Unit Price: As lmproved_____; Unimproved 52,76 Street Concrete Curb & GutteL __________________ Utilities,_A"""ll'--__ Improvments None atS"'a±>le'--________________ _􀁾􀀮________ Size and Description Level, ready for development Condition and 􀁄􀁥􀁳􀁩􀁲􀁡􀁢􀁩􀁊􀁩􀁴􀁹􀁾________ (," . Current Use_-"U"'n"'im"-p"'r"'o"-ve"'d'--______􀁾􀀠Highest and 􀁂􀁥􀁾􀁴􀀠Use Light Industria! & Commercial Date 􀁉􀁮􀁳􀁰􀁥􀁣􀁴􀁥􀁤􀁾􀀷􀀢􀀭􀀯􀀭􀀢􀀱􀀵􀀢􀀧􀀭􀀯􀀢􀀧􀀹􀀩􀀢􀀧􀀭􀀵􀀧􀁟􀁟_______ Zoning Commercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent information ___________-:-_____-c__􀀱􀀯􀀰􀁾􀁌a 􀁾􀁬􀁊􀁐􀁴􀀯􀁻 Appraiser Form 200 la Page 8 #3 CuMPARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEMENT Sales Parties: Grantor --"C"ha!!!i"'u'--'C"'h"'inLL______________ Grantee AER Dated 4/14/95 ____ Recorded in Volume.....z9"'-SO"-7<.::4'--______ _ Page _6"'6"'8'--___ Local Address 2030 Che",na",u",l",t,,--,C,,,a,,IT,,ol.!-lI,,,to,,,nL,,-,T,,,X;l.'__________________________________ Legal Description Abstract 923, Tract 20 . Actual 􀁐􀁲􀁩􀁣􀁥􀀮􀀭􀀢􀀤􀀢􀀬􀀵􀀢􀀢􀀳􀁹􀀧􀀰􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀬􀀵􀀬􀀬􀀬􀁏􀁹􀀧􀀰􀁾􀀮_____________Verified With Pat Haggertv Conditions of 􀁓􀁡􀁬􀁥􀁾􀁳􀀬􀀬􀀬􀁨􀁾______,_________________________________ 􀁒􀁥􀁾􀁡􀁬􀁾􀁾􀁾__ __ ,_______________.__________ ,________________________ Land Size 4.0592 Acres ________ Unit Price: As Improved_______: Unimproved $3.00 Street Concrete Curb & G"'u"'tt"'e"'r________________________ ___ Utilities All Improvments None at Sale Size and Description _______________________________________________ Condition and Desirability ___________________________________________ Current Use Warehouse under constmciton Highest and Best:Use Corrunercial Date Inspected."."I""O""/2"'2",1"'95"-_________ Zoning Commercial-l Use reverse side for other pertinent information AppraIser Texas Turnpike Authority Form 200la ADDISON AIRPORT TUNNEL REAL ESTATE APPRA ISAL REPORT Parcel Number __________ Address Port-O-Port, 4701 & 4700 Keller 􀁾􀁰􀁲􀁩􀁮􀁧􀁳􀀬􀀠Also called tImmcr T-g, T-lD & L-IO (3 Buildings) Owner City ofAddison. Address______________ Occupant's Namc _________ Whole Taking, ____ Partial Taking X Purpose of the Appraisal The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the fee simple title encumbered by existing easements, if any, which are compatible to highway use of the subject property as of 12120/95, It is being made for the Texas Turnpike Authority in connection with the investigation and defense of the claims by the owner of the property for compensation and damages, if any, arising out of the property acquisition by the Texas Turnpike Authority for right-of-way purposes. The estimates of value concluded herein will be used for settlement of sllch claims through negotiation or Clllincnt dOlllilin proceedings, Markct Value may be dcfined as follows: "Market Value is the price wl1ieh the property would bring when it is offcred for sale by one who dcsires, but is not obliged, to sell, and is bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it, taking into consideration all of the uses to which it is reasonable adaptable and for which it either is or in all reasonable probability will become available within the reasonable future," Valuation In my opinion the compensation due as a result ofthis taking is: Owner $_______ Leasehold Interest 􀁾_______ Total $1 18,114. Appraiser's Certificate I hereby eertifY that the opinIOn of value herein expressed has been reached after a careful examination of all pertinent data; that my fee is in no way contingent upon the value placed on the property; that neither I nor any employee in my service has directly or indirectly any financial or personal interest in or to the property appraised; and that should I or nny employee in my service acquire any interest in or to the property appraised prior to the acquisition of the parcel by the Authority, I will immediately notifY the Authority of such interest or interests. ,. J Appraiser Approved by the Board of Directors Right-of-Way 1 Form 2001a Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No. _______ Local Address Port-O-Port, 470 l & 4700 KeJ 1er Springs Also called Hanger T-8, T-10 & L-IO (3 Buildings; 12/10/95 Taken by Charles (Bo) MillerDate Taken _ --....-. .' ,",'-"" . 'l:..,.--------,'1 2. Point from which takcn,___"EAficS;;,.TL..iS1JIUDUEL________ Looking ._"'I<"'E"'S...T_____ Form 200 la Page 2 ATTACH ALL PERTINENT PICTURES Parcel No,_______ Local Address_!?QLC"Q-PQrt. 47Q I & 4700 ReJ J er Springs Also called Hanger T-8, T-IO & L-IO (3 Building'Date Taken 12/10/95 Taken by Charles (Bo) Miller 3. Point from which taken 􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁟􀁊􀁬􀁪􀁊􀀮􀁋􀁛􀁝􀀻􀁌􀀮􀀮􀂧􀁊􀁊􀀲􀁬􀁪􀁾_______ Looking 􀁟􀀭􀀢􀁓􀀢􀀢􀀬􀁏􀀢􀀬􀁴􀀺􀁔􀀮􀀺􀀮􀀡􀁈􀀬􀀢􀀭􀁟􀁾􀁟􀀠• Form 2001a Page 3 DATA ON WHOLE PROPERTY Legal 􀁄􀁥􀁳􀁣􀁲􀁩􀁰􀁴􀁩􀁯􀁮􀁾􀁬􀁬􀁳􀁴􀁲􀁡􀁣􀁴􀀠792 Addison Municipal Airport Dimensions: 65 feet x ..1JL..____feet = 13,780 sq. ft. .3 163 Acres Location (Urban): Street &No. ________􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁯􀁮􀀮􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀀭􀁾􀁳􀁩􀁤􀁥􀀠between --:::--_::---___________ and ____________streets, (Rural): _____􀀭􀀻􀀭􀀭􀀺􀀭􀀺􀀺􀀺􀀭􀁟􀁾􀀻􀁟􀁟􀀭􀀭􀀭__------- ---:7"-;-:';--:--:--;-----;--;;-:--Land Grant Survey _________________ Neighborhood or Area Analysis: Highest and Best Use and Zoning ofSubject Property: COST APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY Estimated Reproduction Cost: 3 Main Buildings: 5.254 ft. @$23.00 per square fooL"" .." .... $120,842. Parking Lot: $1.15 per sQuare ft ... 6.626 sq.ft. 7,620 ......... $ 12.370. Concrete: $2.50 per square ft...l,900 sq.ft. 4,750 Total Reproduction .......... "".......... " ... "".., ............ ""....... " .... " ............ " ............. " $133,212. Less Accrued Depreciation: Physical Deterioration""" ..... " ............. 40%.""""...............""......... " $ 53,285, Functional Obsolescence ..".." ...... " .... " ...... " ........ " ... " ............. " ........ $ -0Economic Obsolescence ""."""""""""""...."""".""."".. """".."""..$ -0Total Depreciation " ......... "",,,,,,, ................ ,,,, ................ ,,.,, ........... " ............... " ...... $ 53,285. Value Building Contributes to Whole Property .. """....."".."".."""..""".." .... """"""...........",,$ 79,927. Garages: ft. @$ per ft ..... """............"""""........".".... " ... $___ Less Depreciation " ............................. " ...... " ................... " .... ""........................... $ $___ Other (Detail) ........................................ " .... " .... ""......."""................ " ..... " ............. .$.___ Less Depreciation ........................... " ........... """........... " ... " ... " ............ " ............... $ $___ Depreciated Value: Landscaping $ , Fencing $ , Walks $ , Drives $ " ................. " .................. " ......... " ............... " ......... $___ Value Improvements Contribute to Whole Property " ... , ............ " ......... " ....... """".... " ........ $ 79,927. LAND .. ""... " .. 13,780 square feet ""$3"".0""0'--__per.sq.ft""..""".".... " ................ " ..... ".",$ 41,340. ESTIMATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH""""""...... " .... " .... """""............""....... " ... ,$121,267. Comment on Depreciation Factors: Building is approximately 15 yrs. old. Reasonable wear and tear is estimated at 40%. Remaining economic life is approximately 25 yrs. Form 2001a Page 4 MARKET DATA APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY (Land Comparables) Purchase Price of Subject Property $_--------Date,__________ Improvements Since Purchase and Estimated Cost: Lease Terms or Rental Agreement: Sales and Information of Comparable Properties SALE NO, 2 SALE DATE GRANTOR-GRANTEE 10131194 Hope Invt. Ltd, Addison. Ltd. 3/2)/95 M&F Development Co Diversco Mann SALE CONFIRMED wrrn Kent HOlle George Roddy 3 04117/95 Chaiu Chin AER Pat Haggertv ADDRESS & LOCATION IN RELATION TO SUBJECT ACTUAL SALE PRICE CONDITIONS OF SALE ESTIMATED UNIT PRICE LEASE OR RENTAL DATA CURRENT USAGE HIGHEST & BEST USE' SIZE PHYSICAL FEATURES 4901 Airport Pkwy, 344.47' E Addison Rd 1 Blk South $742,000. Cash $3.10 Federal Express Distribution Facility Commercial 5.4963 Acres 4500 blk Sunbelt, Approx.667'VV, of Addison Rd 5 blks N, $125,000, Cash $2,76 Unimproved Commercial 1.0382 Acres, 2030 Chenault @Earhart southeast corner $530,500. Cash $300 VVarehouse under Constmction Commercial 4 Acres IMPROVEMENTS Ngne at 􀁾􀁡􀁬􀁥􀀠None at sale None at sale Correlation ofComparable Sales To Subject Property: Use Additional Pages IfNecessary Estimated Land Value ofMarket Data Approach 􀀤􀀮􀀮􀁌􀀷􀀮􀀡􀀮􀁯􀀱􀀮􀀢􀀬􀀬􀀲􀀳􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀼􀀲􀁾􀀮___ Form 2001a Page 5 INCOl'vfE APPROACH WHOLE PROPERTY JUSTIFICATION OF RAlE AND l'vfETHOD OF CAPITALIZATION:,_________ Estimated remaining economic life of􀁩􀁭􀁰􀁲􀁯􀁶􀁥􀁭􀁥􀁮􀁴􀁳􀀢􀀢􀀬􀀲􀀢􀀭􀀵􀀭􀀢􀁹􀀬 􀀬􀀬􀁥􀁡􀁾􀁲􀁳􀀬􀀬􀀭􀀭_______ Stabilized Gross Income............................................$23.1 00. Vacancy 15 % ........................................... $ 3,465. Effective Gross Incomc.................................... , ........................................... , .. , ....................... $19.635. Taxes: City..................................................... ............. , ..... $,....,..-,__ State & County.... } ................................................. $ 1 000. Miscellaneous (School, etc.) .................................... $___ Insurance: Fire & Extended Coverage...................................... $ 102. Miscellaneous.........................................................$._=_ Annual Deferred Maintenance ................................... $ 275. Management 4 % ..................................... $ 1.785. Operating Expenses ................................................... $ ___ Other Expenses ...............................$'--__ Total Expenses before Depreciation ................................................................................. " ..... $ 2,162. Net Inrome to Property ............. , ..................... , .......................... " ........................... , ............... $ 17.473. Less Income Attributable tc (Land)................. ........... $ 41.340. @10.5 % .................... $ 4.341. Income Attributable to (Improvements) ................................................................................... $13.132. Income Capitalized@,"'1"'2__%(....__% 􀁉􀁮􀁴􀁥􀁲􀁥􀁳􀁴􀁾__% for Recapture ofCapital) ..$109,433. (Land) (Improvements) ........ , ............ ,', ......... , ............ , .................................................... , .... $ 41,340. ESTIMAlED VALUE BY CAPITALIZATION APPROACH ............................................$150.773. ADDmONAL APPRAISAL INFORMATION Fonn200la Pagc 6 FINAL ESTIMATE or VALUE OF WHOLE PROPERlY Correlaton of Approaches to Value SeePage 6A Estimated Value ofWllole Property Owner $ Leasehold "'_____ ................................... ....................$,____ 6A CORRELATION The City of Addison owns Addison Airport, which comprises approximately 360 acres ofland. Addison Airport of Texas, Inc. operates, manages, and subleases the airport property, Unless renewed, this agreement tenninates on December 31,2000. There are three approaches to value that may be utilized to estimate fair market value ofthe subject -Market, Income & Reproduction or Replacement Cost. The Market Approach to Value is a basis for estimating value based upon units of comparison derived from sales of similar properties in the marketplace. Those units of comparison are then applied to the subject property to arrive at a range ofvalues which should be indicative of the market estimate ofvalue for the subject property. The Income Approach to Value is based upon an analysis ofthe income stream ofthe property and comparison ofthat income stream with income streams ofsimilar properties. This calculation and analysis results in a net income stream attributable to the real estate. That income is then then capitalized at a rate which is commensurate with the rates expressed in the marketplace by investors for similar properties. The resulting figure is an income estimate of value, The Cost Approach to Value embraces the philosophy that the reproduction costs or the principal ofsubstitution for a property should limit the upper side ofvalue, In this approach to value the appraiser calculates the market value of the site, the reproduction cost ofthe improvements less any applicable depreciation, then combines these two items to arrive at a cost estimate ofvalue. The market approach has been used to estimate the value ofthe land, Sale # I is located one block south ofthe subject and east ofAddison Road, This comparable is slightly superior to the subject as Airport Parkway connects Addison Road and the Dallas North Tollway. Federal Express has constructed a distribution fucility on this property, Sale #2 is approximately 5 blocks north ofthe subject on a secondary street occupied by office showroom and warehouse fucilities, Sale #3 is west ofthe subject and on the west side of Addison Airport in an office warehouse neighborhood. An office warehouse fucility is currently under construction on this property, These comparables give an accurate value for land in the vicinity ofAddison Airport used for conunercial and warehouse uses. After analyzing these sales, a value of $3.00 per square foot is selected as fair market value ofthe land before the taking for the land taken, and for the land value after the taking, At $3.00 per square foot the flUr market value ofthe land is $41,340. A two year temporary construction easement of 13,780 square feet is being taken. Just compensation for the land taken under the construction easement equals $8,68 L The income approach is the most reliable indicator ofvalue ofthe subject. The cost approach indicates an upper limit ofvalue when the improvements are new and constitute the highest and best use for the property. The income stream generated by the property ean be compared to income from other investments available in the market with similar and varied degrees of risk and durability. Direct capitalization -building residual technique is used to estimate the value ofthe property under the income approach. TIre land va ,has been established at $41,340. from C{ arable sales. 10.5% is selected as adequate return on the value ofthe land or $4,341. When this mcome is subtracted from net income to property, $13,132. of income is attributed to the improvements. Capitalizing this income at 12% gives value attributed to the improvements of $109,433. The sums of the value ofland and value ofthe improvements equals the estimated value ofthe whole property of $150,773. The income approach is the most accurate estimate ofthe fuir market value. Therefore $150,800. is the fair market value of the subject before the taking. The value of the remainder before the taking is $41,340. ($150,773. less $109,433.). After the taking, the improvements are completely removed. $109,433. is the value attributed to the improvments. The value ofthe remainder after the taking is unchanged and is equal to $41,340. In addition to taking ofthe improvements and the surfuce easement, a temporary construction easement will be taken. This easement will be needed for a period of2 years. Fair rental value is equal to 10.5% oflhe value of the land for that period (13,780 sq.ft. x$3 x 10.5% x 2 yrs = $8,681.). Total just compensation is summarized as follows: Improvements Taken $109,433. Construction Easement Taken 8,68l. Total Just Compensation $118,114. , : Fonn 2001a Page 7 DATA ON PARTIAL TAKING Legal Description Part Taken ________________________ Dimensions x Sq.Ft. Acres WHOLE PROPERTY: The market value ofthe whole property is .................􀀤􀁬 􀁾􀀰􀀢􀀧􀀢􀀮􀀷􀀧􀁟􀀧􀀷􀀢􀀧􀀳􀁾􀀮__ PART TAKEN: The market value ofthe fee simple title, less oil, gas and sulphur, to the part being taken fur highway purposes, considered as a severed tract is: ........................................................................................ $109.433. (I) REMAINING PROPERTY: The market value ofthe remiander immediately before the taking is:.................. ; ............................................ $ 41.340. (2) Considering the use to which the part taken is to be subjected to, the market value ofthe remainder immediately after the taking is:................................... $ 41.340. (3) NET DAMAGES, ifany ........................................................................................ ...........$_..::!-0>F-__ SIGN ADJUSTMENT COSTS, if any ............................................................................... $:7;:..::-0":::-;:-TOTAL COMPENSATION.......................... ..................................................... $109,433. APPRAISALS OF PART TAKEN AND REMAINDER Highest and Best Use of 􀁐􀁡􀁲􀁴􀁔􀁡􀁫􀁥􀁮􀁾􀁾􀁾􀁾____________􀁾_________________ Remainder Before Taking -:-:-:-__.,--__-:-;-:--;-_________________ Remainder after taking considering the use to which the parttaken is to be subjected.__________________________________ Contributory Value of Improvements Part Taken Remainder Before Taking Remainder After Taking Bldg.-5,254 (100%) $109.433. TOTAL IMPROVEMENTS 109.433. 41.340. 4\,340. TOTALASAUNlT $109,433. (I) $ 41,340 (2) $ 41,340. (3) CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT + 8,681. $118,114. Form 2001a Page 8 #1 C(J",{PARABLE SALES DATA SUPPLEM&", 􀁉􀁴􀀭􀁾􀀭􀀭􀀻􀀭􀀺􀀮􀀭􀀮􀀭􀀭􀀮􀀭􀁾􀀠􀀭􀁾􀀧􀀭􀀧---',.. .....-----,.--c;-:= Sales Parties: Grantor Hope Investment Ltd.. ______ Grantee Addison Ltd. Dated,_-£lO"'I""3""1/""94'"--_._____ Recorded in Volume""9c.c4",2,,,10,--_____ Page 3570 Local Address 4901 Aimor! Parkway Legal Description Abst. 482. Tract 􀀳􀁾􀀮􀀠Ad